Saturday, 13 June 2009

Colorado man awaits freedom after conviction tossed

Associated Press
Sunday, May 24, 2009


Associated Press

LIMON — Tim Kennedy tugs at the Department of Corrections No. 94886 tag on his green-blue prison uniform and says with a smile: "This number and stuff are dead. My convictions are overturned and I'm no longer a convicted felon. I'm all new."

Kennedy, 52, is hoping to be freed after he is transferred this week from a prison in Limon to El Paso County, where a judge overturned his conviction in a 1991 double murder and ordered a new trial.

El Paso County District Judge Thomas Kane's decision April 21 to toss out Kennedy's conviction in the slayings of 15-year-old Jennifer Carpenter and her boyfriend, 37-year-old Steve Staskiewicz, followed years of appeals capped by a 14-day hearing during which another possible suspect was named.

Kennedy could be released after a hearing Tuesday if prosecutors decide to drop the case or agree to $50,000 bail sought by Kennedy's attorneys, Kathleen Carlson and John Dicke, who have been fighting for Kennedy's release since 2006.

El Paso County District Attorney Dan May has declined to talk publicly about the case.

During an interview Thursday at the Limon Correctional Facility on the Eastern Plains about 95 miles east of Denver, Kennedy cherished the thought of being a free man. Apart from spending time with his sister and brother, one of the first things Kennedy would do if he is freed is get a steak dinner.

"It's really great to think that I actually have a chance at getting my life back," he said. "I tell you what, boy, it's been a long, long haul."

Carpenter, a runaway, was the alleged victim in a 1991 case accusing Charles Stroud and Rebecca Corkins of kidnapping and sexually assaulting her. Prosecutors had learned that a "hit" had been put out on Carpenter and were scrambling to take her testimony under oath when she and Staskiewicz were slain in his trailer.

Kennedy had lent Staskiewicz, his friend, two TVs and a stereo for entertainment while the couple waited out the hit. Kennedy also lent Staskiewicz three guns for protection, including an AMT 380 handgun that was the murder weapon.

After the killings, Kennedy said, investigators immediately tried connecting him to Stroud and Corkins, whom he had never met. Kennedy was interviewed by an investigator at his apartment, which along with his car, was searched 10 days after the slaying.

"They didn't find anything," Carlson said, "which is an interesting part of this case because the scene is extremely bloody."

Nevertheless, investigators arrested Kennedy nearly five years later. Their theory: Kennedy killed Staskiewicz and Carpenter over the items, including the guns, he had lent them.

Kennedy grew up in Denver and worked as a carpenter, helping build several of downtown Denver's skyscrapers. His only brush with the law before the slayings was a minor offense of possession of an injection device. He was trying to start a trash collection business in Colorado Springs when he came under suspicion for the slayings.

He was living with his parents in Denver when El Paso County sheriff's deputies arrested him on Dec. 21, 1995. He had just finished eating breakfast and was planning to decorate the family Christmas tree.

"I got a phone call. And it says, 'Yeah, Mr. Kennedy, this is the sheriff's department. We're outside. We need you to come out to the front yard,'" Kennedy recounted.

He's been in custody ever since.

At trial, the only physical evidence linking Kennedy to the crime was the FBI's comparative bullet lead analysis, which purported to be able to trace a bullet from a crime scene to a box of bullets in a suspect's possession. That technique has since been discredited as "exceeding the limits of science" and the FBI stopped the analysis in 2005.

"This was the first time that I really had any involvement in the justice system," Kennedy said. "I had faith in the justice system. So did my parents. I thought justice worked in this country, I really did."

In overturning Kennedy's conviction, Judge Kane listed several factors that could win Kennedy an acquittal:

— His defense attorney at trial failed to develop an adequate alternative suspect theory by relying on investigative files and not interviewing witnesses who had information about a murder conspiracy involving other people.

— The FBI's comparative bullet lead analysis.

— Prosecutors had a jailhouse letter in their files as part of another case that should have been turned over to Kennedy's attorney that could have been used to prove his innocence. There are no allegations of wrongdoing by prosecutors.

— Lack of DNA evidence on the victims' clothing and on a sponge believed to have been used as a silencer during the slayings.

Investigators said the killer dragged Staskiewicz's body across the floor and carried Carpenter's body "like a bride" over to Staskiewicz. DNA tests conducted by Dutch expert Richard Eikelenboom for Kennedy's lawyers found none of Kennedy's DNA on clothing where the killer would have touched the victims, or on the sponge.

Eikelenboom's testing helped overturn the conviction and life sentence of Timothy Masters in the 1987 slaying of Peggy Hettrick in Fort Collins. Masters, freed in January 2008, was the first person in Colorado released from prison because of DNA evidence. Hettrick's slaying remains unsolved.

Based on witness testimony at trial, Dicke believes Staskiewicz and Carpenter let their guard down and allowed a friend into the trailer, who then used Kennedy's gun to kill the couple when they fell asleep.

That friend has been named in court documents but has not been charged in the slayings. That friend was also quoted by a witness in court as saying he used "some dumb (expletive's)" gun and called it "a gift from God."

"I wouldn't mind going to trial," Kennedy said. "You know, all these people think it will be a nightmare. I really wouldn't mind. I'm not scared at all."

Kennedy's mother, Lois June Kennedy, died in 2005 at the age of 83. His father, John Francis Kennedy, died in 2007 at age 85.

"There are times when it brings you to tears when you think about how lucky you are, how things have worked out, how your family stayed with you," Kennedy said. "There's a lot of wonderful things that have come out of this situation. You know, I'll never forget my parents. They spent their life savings (on his defense). Even after that you know, they stuck with me through the rest of their lives.

"There was never any suspicion or fear or nothing at all because they know I'm not a murderer."

Corkins completed a prison sentence in 1997 for criminal attempt and drug abuse stemming from the original Carpenter case, according to Department of Corrections records.

Corkins said recently she was surprised when she was served a subpoena last year to testify as part of Kennedy's request for a new trial. She said she didn't know about the slayings until she saw it on television in 1991.

Stroud is serving a 50-year sentence in a state prison in Canon City for kidnapping in the Carpenter case. Stroud declined a request for comment sent through prison officials.

Tuesday, 19 May 2009

Another View: Let plaintiffs sue for prosecutorial abuse

The U.S. Supreme Court's decision to hear an appeal of an Iowa case means that two men who were wrongly convicted of murder 31 years ago may wait at least another year before their civil suit against their prosecutors could be heard. That's the optimistic view.

A less optimistic view is that Terry Harrington and Curtis McGee may never have the opportunity to make their case in civil court that former Pottawattamie County prosecutors allegedly conspired to convict them of a murder they did not commit.

The nine members of the Supreme Court who will ultimately rule in this case are the only ones who know for sure which way this case is headed. If the court wanted to uphold the lower-court decision that had cleared the civil suit to proceed, it could have simply declined to hear this appeal and gotten out of the road.

Accepting the case suggests at least some of the justices think prosecutors should be totally immune from lawsuits, which goes too far. While prosecutors need some protection to do their jobs, the door should not be entirely closed against using the civil-justice system to explore the truth of claims of outrageous prosecutorial abuse.

That is precisely what the two plaintiffs in the Pottawattamie case assert happened. Harrington and McGee, two black teenagers from Omaha, were convicted in 1978 by a Pottawattamie County jury in the shooting death of a retired Council Bluffs police captain who was working as a night watchman. Both insist to this day they were, and are, innocent.

In their civil suit, Harrington and McGee say their first-degree murder convictions — which were overturned by the Iowa Supreme Court 25 years later — were the result of the worst sort of prosecutorial misconduct. Their suit brought in federal court in Des Moines alleges that former Pottawattamie County Attorney David Richter and his then-deputy Joseph Hrvol not only manufactured evidence against them but concealed evidence of a stronger suspect.

State and federal prosecutors in the course of executing their official duties generally enjoy immunity from suits under state laws and judicial decisions. Robert Pratt, chief judge of the Southern District of Iowa, ruled that the doctrine of prosecutorial immunity does not protect prosecutors for misconduct that carries over to the trial from the evidence-gathering phase. The Eighth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, based in St. Louis, Mo., upheld Pratt on that point, but other circuit courts have taken a different view. Because there is disagreement among the lower federal appellate courts on this point, the U.S. Supreme Court is now poised to settle the issue.

There is a case to be made that the public has an interest in protecting prosecutors from having to defend themselves every time a criminal prosecution goes wrong. But does that mean a criminal defendant can never bring a lawsuit against prosecutors responsible for outrageous conduct? Does the Constitution have nothing to say about prosecutors who conspire to convict the innocent?

In an age when convicted murderers are being released from death row based on new DNA evidence and when prior criminal convictions are being overturned because of clear prosecutorial misconduct — the most recent being that of former Alaska Sen. Ted Stevens — it's time for the courts to reconsider a rule that gives total protection to prosecutors who abuse their powers.

(Source : www.statesmanjournal.com)

Tennessee: Exoneration After 22 Years on Death Row


Prosecutors dropped charges against a former Tennessee inmate who spent 22 years on death row before new evidence cast doubt on his guilt. The district attorney said DNA tests presented “a reasonable doubt” about whether the former inmate, Paul House, 48, acted alone in the murder of a woman near Knoxville in 1985. “This is the day we’ve been waiting for 24 years,” said Joyce House, his mother. “The tears have been flowing, and I’ve been dancing.” In 2006, the United States Supreme Court ruled that Mr. House was entitled to a new trial. He was released from prison in July and placed on house arrest. DNA from key evidence, including semen on the victim’s clothing and blood beneath her fingernails, does not match Mr. House. Prosecutors said in a petition that they still suspected Mr. House of murder, possibly with accomplices, but a judge accepted their request to drop the charges.

(Source : www.nytimes.com)

Monday, 18 May 2009

Prosecutors Block Access to DNA Testing for Inmates

By SHAILA DEWAN

In an age of advanced forensic science, the first step toward ending Kenneth Reed’s prolonged series of legal appeals should be simple and quick: a DNA test, for which he has offered to pay, on evidence from the 1991 rape of which he was convicted.

Louisiana, where Mr. Reed is in prison, is one of 46 states that have passed laws to enable inmates like him to get such a test. But in many jurisdictions, prosecutors are using new arguments to get around the intent of those laws, particularly in cases with multiple defendants, when it is not clear how many DNA profiles will be found in a sample.

The laws were enacted after DNA evidence exonerated a first wave of prisoners in the early 1990s, when law enforcement authorities strongly resisted reopening old cases. Continued resistance by prosecutors is causing years of delay and, in some cases, eliminating the chance to try other suspects because the statute of limitations has passed by the time the test is granted.

Mr. Reed has been seeking a DNA test for three years, saying it will prove his innocence. But prosecutors have refused, saying he was identified by witnesses, making his identification by DNA unnecessary.

A recent analysis of 225 DNA exonerations by Brandon L. Garrett, a professor at the University of Virginia School of Law, found that prosecutors opposed DNA testing in almost one out of five cases. In many of the others, they initially opposed testing but ultimately agreed to it. In 98 of those 225 cases, the DNA test identified the real culprit.

In Illinois, prosecutors have opposed a DNA test for Johnnie Lee Savory, convicted of committing a double murder when he was 14, on the grounds that a jury was convinced of his guilt without DNA and that the 175 convicts already exonerated by DNA were “statistically insignificant.”

In the case of Robert Conway, a mentally incapacitated man convicted of stabbing a shopkeeper to death in 1986 in Pennsylvania, prosecutors have objected that DNA tests on evidence from the scene would not be enough to prove his innocence.

And in Tennessee, prosecutors withdrew their consent to DNA testing for Rudolph Powers, convicted of a 1980 rape, because the victim had an unidentified consensual sex partner shortly before the attack.

Such arguments, defense lawyers say, often ignore scientific advances like the ability to identify multiple DNA profiles in a single sample.

Defense lawyers also say the arguments ignore the proven power of DNA to refute almost every other type of evidence.

In a case before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, for example, Lynne Abraham, the Philadelphia district attorney, argued that the defendant, Anthony Wright, was not entitled to DNA testing because of the overwhelming evidence presented at trial, including his confession, four witnesses and clothing stained with the victims’ blood that the police said was found at Mr. Wright’s home. The Pennsylvania DNA statute requires the courts to determine if there is a “reasonable possibility” that the test would prove innocence.

Prosecutors say they are concerned that convicts will seek DNA testing as a delay tactic or a fishing expedition, and that allowing DNA tests undermines hard-won jury verdicts and opens the floodgates to overwhelming requests.

“It’s definitely a matter of drawing the line somewhere,” said Peter Carr, the assistant district attorney who handled the case of Mr. Wright, who was accused of raping and killing a 77-year-old woman. The defendant did not request testing until 2005, three years after the statute was passed, Mr. Carr said, and in his view there was no possibility that the test would show innocence.

“There’s also the idea that you want finality for the victim’s sake,” Mr. Carr said. “If someone else’s semen was found at the crime scene, we’d have to talk to the victim’s family about whether the victim was sexually active.”

Barry Scheck, a co-founder of the Innocence Project, a New York legal advocacy group that uses DNA to help the wrongfully convicted, said that most prosecutors no longer resisted testing in cases like Mr. Wright’s, where there is one perpetrator. More obstacles arise, Mr. Scheck said, in cases with multiple defendants or cases where a test result might point to another suspect, even if it does not clearly prove the innocence of the defendant.

In one such case near Austin, Tex., a defendant who was convicted in the bludgeoning death of his wife requested a DNA test on a bloody bandanna found 100 feet from the house. On its own, a test of the bandanna would not prove the guilt or innocence of the defendant the same way testing semen in a rape case might. But if it matched DNA found at the scene of a similar crime in the same county, or DNA in a database of convicted felons, it would be significant evidence that someone else might be responsible — the kind of evidence that might plant a reasonable doubt in a juror’s mind or lead to a confession by a perpetrator.

Although such matches have been found in many cases, most state DNA statutes focus only on whether a test alone could prove innocence. The purpose of Tennessee’s DNA statute, a court there said, was “to establish the innocence of the petitioner and not to create conjecture or speculation that the act may have possibly been perpetrated by a phantom defendant.”

Law enforcement officials often say, “ ‘We’re not going to consider the possibility that a third party did it,’ ” Mr. Scheck said, adding, “which is completely crazy because you use the databank every day to make new criminal cases.”

In Mr. Reed’s case in East Baton Rouge Parish, the district attorney who first prosecuted the case and now his successor, Hillar C. Moore III, have appealed every DNA-related ruling in Mr. Reed’s favor and objected to even a hearing on the matter.

They have argued that Mr. Reed’s identity was not an issue in the trial because he was identified by the defendant, even though DNA evidence has repeatedly contradicted eyewitness identifications. They have argued that there was no way of knowing whether the evidence would yield a usable DNA profile — a question that would be settled by testing it.

The victim testified that two attackers had sexual intercourse with her, but the prosecutors now argue that it might have been only one, Mr. Reed’s accomplice. Even if Mr. Reed’s DNA was nowhere to be found, said Prem Burns, the first assistant district attorney, he would still be guilty of aiding the rapist.

Mr. Reed’s lawyers have argued that a test on a rape kit and semen could prove his innocence if it shows two distinct profiles and neither is a match.

But Ms. Burns said that under her reading of the law, the mere possibility that the test would show two profiles is not enough — Mr. Reed has to demonstrate, in advance, that a favorable test result would resolve his innocence without question.

But the prosecutors also seem to believe that Mr. Reed’s arguments are far-fetched. “There are simply too many ‘ifs’ in this case,” Mr. Moore wrote in a recent appeal.

Prosecutors said much the same when Douglas Warney, convicted of murder in Rochester in 1997, argued that a DNA test could lead to the real killer. They called his assertion “a drawn-out kind of sequence of if, if, if.” Yet that is exactly what happened after Mr. Warney’s DNA test, and the killer, when he was identified, confessed.

Nina Morrison, a lawyer for Mr. Wright, said: “The one thing I’ve learned in doing this for seven years is there’s no reason to guess or speculate. You can just do the test.

Torture and False Confessions

Much of the media storm around torture these days focuses on the moral compromise the U.S. made under the Bush administration to break international codes of conduct and on whether good intelligence came from these brutal interrogations. I think the problem is even worse than a dearth of good intelligence. Torture produces bad, incorrect intelligence, and criminal cases in the U.S. are irrefutable evidence of this.

Yesterday, the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee heard from a former FBI agent that harsh interrogations techniques used on suspected al-Qaeda operative Abu Zubaydah were "ineffective, slow and unreliable, and as a result harmful to our efforts to defeat al- Qaeda." Back in January we learned that much of the information in the 9/11 Commission Report came from confessions obtained using "enhanced interrogation techniques." Center on Constitutional Rights told NBC that he was shocked the commission hadn't asked about the techniques used to obtain crucial information.

Ratner argues "if they suspected there was torture, they should have realized that as a matter of law, evidence derived from torture is not reliable, in part because of the possibility of false confession…at the very least, they should have added caveats to all those references."

DNA testing has shown again and again in criminal cases that false confessions are real, and there's no doubt in my mind that torture leads to false information as well. As I've mentioned before, I work at the Innocence Project when I'm not blogging here at change.org, and many of our cases have shown the power of emotional and physical abuse from law enforcement officers to force someone to admit to something they didn't do. About 25% of wrongful convictions overturned by DNA testing have involved a false confession or admission. If one-quarter of information gleaned from torture was false – leading to wrongful arrests and convictions and to costly goose chases – would Dick Cheney still say it was worth it?

News reports have shown that top Bush officials repeatedly ordered agents to torture captives in an attempt to tie al-Qaeda to Iraq. If you torture someone long enough, you can get them to say anything.
Jeff Deskovic was 16 years old when he was interrogated for a murder in his small upstate New York town. Despite DNA evidence before his trial that another man committed the crime, police believed Jeff was involved and set out to prove it through a harsh interrogation. Jeff was asked again and again if he did it, and how he did it. After six hours, three polygraphs and no food, Deskovic was in the fetal position under a table ready to admit to anything. He said he committed the crime, and he spent 16 years in prison before the same DNA evidence pointed to the real perpetrator.

On Monday, a California court ruled that fake polygraphs are admissible evidence in court proceedings, virtually ensuring that there will be more Jeff Deskovics. Also this week, former Chicago Detective Jon Burge testified in a hearing in Florida about his alleged involvement in the torture of a suspect who was later wrongfully convicted. He is facing charges relating to the abuses that allegedly went on under his watch over more than a decade on Chicago's South Side - including the use of beatings, electrocutions and other forms of torture to extract confessions. We now know that many of those confessions were false.

The solution to preventing wrongful convictions - once we pass the common-sense hurdle of not allowing ridiculously unjust tactics like false polygraphs - is to videotape all custodial interrogations. Interrogation techniques used by police will be in plain sight before judges, juries, prosecutors and defense attorneys, and the tapes will be valuable in helping investigators solve crimes and train new officers. Torture by police will become far less commonplace, and false confessions will go the same way.

The torture of suspected terrorists isn't only earning us the moral disdain of much of the world, it's also gathering piles of false information and possibly contributing to the detention and conviction of innocent people. Perhaps we need to think about recording interrogations at our secret prisons abroad as well.

Texas House OKs wrongful conviction bill

By JEFF CARLTON Associated Press Writer © 2009 The Associated Press
May 14, 2009, 4:04PM

DALLAS — With the help of DNA testing, Texas has freed more wrongly convicted people than any other state. Soon it will compensate them better than any other state, too.
The Texas House has agreed with changes made in the Senate on a bill to boost payments to the wrongly convicted, voting 132-13 for the measure Thursday. It now heads to Gov. Rick Perry.

The governor is expected to sign the legislation, which is named for Tim Cole, a Fort Worth man who died in prison in 1999 while serving time for a rape that DNA testing later showed he did not commit. Last month in Austin, Perry met with Cole's family and was photographed hugging Cole's sobbing mother.

The bill increases lump sum payments from $50,000 to $80,000 for every year of confinement and grants an annuity to provide a lifetime of income. Exonerees will get 120 hours of paid tuition at a career center or public college. Senators removed a provision to provide health insurance coverage for exonerees.

It also provides an additional $25,000 for each year a wrongly convicted person spends on parole or as a registered sex offender. No other state has such a provision, said Barry Scheck, the co-director of The Innocence Project, a New York-based legal center specializing in overturning wrongly convictions.

The bill would give the wrongly convicted in Texas the most generous compensation package in the nation.

"It is a landmark bill," Scheck said. "For a fixed damage award, it's the highest in the country."

Cory Session, Cole's brother, said his brother died "a martyr for innocence." The likely passage of the bill, he said, makes "you walk a little taller and stick out your chest out a little farther."

"Almost 25 years ago, the only thing people knew about Tim Cole's name was he was a convicted rapist," Session said. "Now they know his name stands for a lot more."
The compensation applies only to wrongly convicted people who were actually innocent. Those whose convictions are reversed on technicalities such as insufficient evidence would not be eligible. Also ineligible would be exonerees who are subsequently convicted of felonies.
By accepting state compensation, the wrongly convicted must agree not to sue the state, a factor in attracting support from municipalities such as Dallas, where many of the wrongly convicted are from. There are 39 people in Texas who qualify for compensation, said Kevin Glasheen, a Lubbock attorney who represents some of the exonerees and led the lobbying efforts for the bill. Nineteen are from Dallas.

"The fact that Texas did have such a problem also means these guys had comparatively good claims," Glasheen said. "It is a local government cost-saving measure, ultimately.

"It's a good trade off. It gives guys a quick, fair way of resolving claims without having to go through lengthy court battles."

Monday, 30 March 2009

Innocence Project Founders Neufeld and Scheck to Receive Jefferson Medal in Law


Posted March 19, 2009


Innocence Project Founders Neufeld and Scheck to Receive Jefferson Medal in Law
Barry C. Scheck and Peter J. Neufeld


Contact: Mary Wood


Barry C. Scheck and Peter J. Neufeld, founders of the Innocence Project, will be awarded the 2009 Thomas Jefferson Foundation Medal in Law during the University's Founder's Day festivities in April.
"Nothing the legal system does is more important than adjudicating criminal guilt and innocence," said Dean Paul G. Mahoney. "Barry Scheck and Peter Neufeld have worked tirelessly to identify and remedy mistaken convictions and by so doing have served the interests not merely of their clients, but of justice."

Created in 1992 as a nonprofit legal clinic affiliated with the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, the Innocence Project advocates for post-conviction DNA testing to exonerate the wrongfully convicted and pushes for other reforms that might prevent future wrongful convictions.
Post-conviction DNA testing has helped free more than 200 innocent people, 17 of whom had been sentenced to death. The Innocence Project today includes a network of clinics across the country, including one launched by the Law School in 2008.

In addition to co-directing the Innocence Project, Neufeld and Scheck also have a civil rights litigation practice, Cochran Neufeld & Scheck, which has represented such high-profile clients as Abner Louima and Earl Washington.

The Thomas Jefferson Medal in Law and its counterparts in architecture and civic leadership are the highest external honors bestowed by the University, which grants no honorary degrees. The awards recognize the achievements of those who embrace endeavors that Jefferson — author of the Declaration of Independence, third U.S. president and founder of the University of Virginia — excelled in and held in high regard.

Sponsored jointly by the University and the Thomas Jefferson Foundation, the nonprofit organization that owns and operates Monticello, the annual awards are conferred during the University's Founder's Day celebrations, held around Jefferson's April 13 birthday. In addition to receiving a medal struck for the occasion, recipients will attend ceremonies in the Rotunda and a dinner at Monticello.

Previous recipients of the medal include several U.S. Supreme Court justices, Sen. Sam Nunn, and former Secretary of State Warren Christopher.

Scheck, a professor of law at Cardozo, serves as commissioner on the New York State Commission on Forensic Science, which regulates the state's crime and forensic DNA laboratories. He is also the first vice president of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and a board member of the National Institute of Justice's Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence.

Scheck previously served as a member of the National Institute of Justice Commission on the Future of DNA Evidence (1997-2000), as an advisor for the Attorney General's Initiative on DNA Laboratory Backlogs (AGID-LAB), on the advisory board for the Celera Genetic Project to Identify Dead at World Trade Center, and on the American Bar Association Special President’s Commission on High Profile Trials (1995-97).

Scheck has represented Hedda Nussbaum, Louie Simpson and O. J. Simpson. He received a J.D. and M.C.P. from the University of California at Berkeley in 1974 and a B.S. from Yale in 1971.
Neufeld also serves on the New York State Commission on Forensic Science. He is a member of the Board of Trustees for Montefiore Medical Center, the University Hospital and Academic Medical Center for the Albert Einstein College of Medicine.

This month Neufeld appeared before the U.S. Supreme Court in District Attorney’s v. Osborne, a case involving whether a criminal defendant has a post-conviction right to access DNA evidence, and whether the defendant can sue to vindicate that right. A former trial advocacy instructor at Fordham University Law School, Neufeld has taught and published extensively on the intersection of science and law, including the proper use of expert witnesses. Neufeld received his J.D. from New York University in 1975 and a B.A. from the University of Wisconsin in 1972.

Neufeld and Scheck met while working at the Legal Aid Society in the Bronx. They are co-authors with Jim Dwyer of “Actual Innocence: Five Days to Execution and Other Dispatches from the Wrongly Convicted.” Both attorneys have received numerous awards for their efforts on behalf of defending civil liberties and for their impact on criminal justice.

http://www.law.virginia.edu/html/news/2009_spr/tj_medal.htm

Wednesday, 25 March 2009

Arrest in 2007 rape case leads to suit


Arrest in 2007 rape case leads to suit


By Jeremy Pawloski The Olympian • Published March 24, 2009


A man who lived in an underground shelter in Watershed Park in Olympia has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the Olympia Police Department alleging false arrest and wrongful imprisonment after he was arrested for the 2007 rape of an 11-year-old girl.


Olympia police arrested David Lukas Lynch on Feb. 6, 2007, after an Olympia police officer found Lynch outside of a southeast Olympia church near where the attack occurred. According to court records, Lynch had a notebook that described his "need to get over his 'child hunting game.' "


Prosecutors dismissed charges against Lynch on Feb. 22, after DNA taken from the victim did not match Lynch's DNA.


A man who lived in the same neighborhood as the girl, Peter James Inouye, 26, was convicted of the girl's rape in November 2008. Inouye's DNA matched the DNA that was taken from the rape victim, according to court testimony. In January, Inouye was sentenced to more than 60 years in prison.


A defense attorney representing the city of Olympia, Donald Law, has filed a response to Lynch's civil lawsuit, stating that "the plaintiff's detention and arrest were lawful." Olympia Police Cmdr. Tor Bjornstad said late Monday that he has not seen the suit, and referred comment to the attorney representing the city.


According to the suit, which was filed in U.S. District Court in Tacoma:


The evening after the rape, Olympia Police Officer Mike Hovda saw a man sitting on the east side of a church off of McCormick Street. The man, Lynch, appeared to look at the officer, and Hovda drove up to him. Lynch was writing in his journal in a "well-lighted parking lot." Lynch did not initially respond when Hovda asked him what he was doing.


Lynch had "shoulder length brown hair and pale skin" and "did not match the description given by the victim."


The victim had described her attacker as having short hair, "black and flat," wearing glasses with circular lenses and white frames. She also described him as having a thin mustache.


Hovda called for backup, and three more Olympia officers arrived. Hovda asked Lynch his name, and Lynch provided it. Hovda asked Lynch if he could search him for weapons, and Lynch stood up and complied. Hovda "asked him if he felt bad about something he might have done, making reference to the rape that had occurred the night before. Hovda asked him specifically if he had entered a house last night and David replied, 'I did not break into any house last night. I did not hurt anyone.' "


The officers began questioning Lynch, and Sgt. Aaron Jelcick later told Lynch, "We know you did it, Mr. Lynch. Just tell us why."


"At no time during this conversation was Mr. Lynch advised of his rights," reads the suit. It also contends that because of "the officers' questioning" and "show of force" that he did not feel free to leave. The suit said Lynch immediately asked for an attorney.


When officers told Lynch he was going with them for questioning, he "believed he was under arrest at that time. He did not feel he had any choice but to go with the officers."
While at the church, Jelcick searched Lynch's backpack and started reading from his notebook. Jelcick told Lynch that "everybody had skeletons that they were ashamed of and it was those people who stood accountable for their actions that would ultimately gain the respect of others," reads the suit.


The next day, Olympia police issued a news release stating that Lynch "matched the description of the rapist," reads the suit.


According to the suit, probable cause for Lynch's arrest was not developed until after they brought him to the police station.


"A photographic montage was done with the victim, but she did not identify Mr. Lynch," reads the suit.


Lynch was subsequently arrested and charged with several felonies, including first-degree burglary, first-degree child rape and first-degree assault of a child.


'Breakdown'
"During Mr. Lynch's incarceration for crimes he did not commit, he suffered a psychological breakdown which included him attempting to chew his wrists to the point of bleeding to death," the suit reads. "He was subsequently sent to Western State Hospital" where he "developed a deep vein thrombosis and a pulmonary embolism which required further medical treatment at St. Claire Hospital in Lakewood."


The suit said Lynch continues to suffer physically and psychologically as a result of the arrest.
The suit alleges that "(P)rior to February 6, 2007, the City of Olympia developed and maintained policies and customs exhibiting deliberate indifference to the constitutional right(s) of persons in the City of Olympia," and that "it was a policy and/or custom of the city of Olympia to inadequately and improperly investigate citizen complaints of police misconduct and the acts of misconduct were instead tolerated by the City of Olympia, including but not limited to the following incidents."

DNA evidence points to another man in 1984 rape


DNA evidence points to another man in 1984 rape


FRANK GREEN AND REED WILLIAMS TIMES-DISPATCH STAFF WRITERS


Published: March 24, 2009


One of the Richmond area's most notorious rapists, Leon W. Davis, also known as the "Black Ninja," has been implicated in a 1984 rape for which another man was convicted.
According to court records, Davis' genetic profile was "consistent with" the DNA profile identified in semen from the scene of a Jan. 3, 1984, rape in Richmond. Thomas E. Haynesworth, a man Davis once described as a friend, was sent to prison for the crime.


Testing by the Virginia Department of Forensic Science did not find Haynesworth's DNA and Richmond authorities are now investigating. However, Richmond Commonwealth's Attorney Michael N. Herring would not comment yesterday on Davis.


Henrico County Commonwealth's Attorney Wade Kizer said police there are still searching through files to see if there might be something to test in connection with a Jan. 30, 1984, rape in Henrico for which Haynesworth was also convicted.


Reached last week by telephone at the Greensville Correctional Center, Haynesworth said of Davis, "I knew all along he was the man. I told my lawyer. I told [police]. He lived right down the street from me."


"I told them: 'This man fit the description.' But nobody ever listened to me," he complained. "Everybody said we looked alike. Only difference between me and him, he is taller and weighed more," said Haynesworth.


Davis, 45, is serving seven life terms for several sexual assaults in Richmond and Henrico, plus assault and robbery charges in two other cases.


Haynesworth, 43, was convicted of rape in Richmond and Henrico and an attempted abduction and robbery in Richmond. He is serving a total of 74 years. He was acquitted of charges that he sodomized a woman at knifepoint on Jan. 21, 1984.


The attacks for which Davis and Haynesworth were convicted occurred throughout 1984. It appears from news accounts at the time that all of the sexual assaults were committed by a man armed with a knife -- except the Jan. 30 rape in Henrico, one of the cases for which Haynesworth was convicted.


However, in that case, a trial transcript shows the victim testified that her attacker told her she was not his first victim and would not be his last. "He said he usually used a kitchen knife but he decided to use a gun this time," she testified.


In December 1984, after Haynesworth had been convicted of the Richmond and Henrico rapes, police warned area women that a man who sometimes called himself the "Black Ninja" was suspected of attacking 12 women in Richmond and Henrico starting that April. Haynesworth had been arrested that February.


According to Henrico Circuit Court records, when Davis was arrested on Dec. 19, 1984, and read his rights, Richmond police reported that he told them: "He discussed his old neighborhood and advised that Haynesworth was a friend of his."


Haynesworth was sentenced to a total of 64 years for his other crimes. Even if he is cleared of the Richmond rape, he must satisfy the terms of his other sentences, unless material is found to test in those cases and those tests also support innocence. He was convicted years before parole was abolished and has been eligible for discretionary parole since 1993.


The recent DNA testing was performed as part of the Virginia Department of Forensic Science's post-conviction project aimed at clearing people who may have been wrongly convicted from 1973 through 1988, before forensic DNA testing was widely available.


Kizer said it was his understanding that the department of forensic science had not been able to find any evidence to test from the Henrico rape.


However, Richmond authorities, in an effort to compel a DNA sample from Davis to verify the match in the state data bank, filed an affidavit Friday as part of a search warrant obtained in Buckingham County Circuit Court. Davis is an inmate at the Buckingham Correctional Center.
The affidavit notes that in DNA testing earlier this month, Haynesworth "was eliminated as a contributor of the DNA profiles that were found foreign to the victim" of the Richmond rape.
"The foreign DNA profiles were searched against the DNA data bank and were found to be consistent with . . . Leon W. Davis," wrote a Richmond detective in the affidavit.


Shawn Armbrust, with the Mid-Atlantic Innocence Project, which is representing Haynesworth, was pleased to learn of the DNA implicating Davis.


"It seems that this evidence clearly proves that Mr. Haynesworth is innocent of the Richmond rape, and we hope the commonwealth's attorney is going to be working with us as quickly as possible to rectify that conviction," said Armbrust.


Contact Frank Green at (804) 649-6340 or fgreen@timesdispatch.com

Contact Reed Williams at (804) 649-6332 or rwilliams@timesdispatch.com

Saturday, 14 March 2009

Giving credit where credit is due


From the Blog : The Defense Rests :



Thursday, March 12, 2009

Giving credit where credit is due


Harris County District Attorney Pat Lykos blasted the Houston Police Department and her predecessor for their roles in the wrongful conviction and imprionment of Ricardo Rachell, who was exonerated in a sexual assault after DNA was (finally) performed on samples taken back in 2002. Mr. Rachell spent more than five years in prison.


Ms. Lykos called for DNA testing in every case in which testing is available and relevant. In addition, Ms. Lykos repeated her call for the shuttering of the HPD Crime Lab and the creation of a regional crime lab, possibly under the auspices of the Harris County Medical Examiner's Office. The National Academy of Sciences called for the creation of regional crime labs in a recent report exposing problems in today's forensic sciences.


County Judge Ed Emmett, Houston Mayor Bill White and HPD Chief Harold Hurtt all expressed support for the proposal.


Mr. Rachell proclaimed his innocence before, during and after his trial, even going so far as to blame Andrew Wayne Hawthorne for the assaults. Mr. Hawthorne has since been charged with the assault. The DNA testing performed on the rape kit from 2002 excluded Mr. Rachell and pointed toward Mr. Hawthorne.


Ms. Lykos deserves credit for acknowledging that there are innocent people serving time in prison. She likewise deserves credit for her proposal to take the crime lab out of HPD's jurisdiction and put it under a department with no stake in the outcome of a criminal case.

Friday, 13 March 2009

Joseph Fears Exonerated in Ohio


Joseph Fears Exonerated in Ohio


Posted: March 12, 2009 2:52 pm


On Tuesday, Joseph Fears, Jr., walked out of an Ohio courthouse a free man for the first time in more than a quarter-century. DNA testing proved that he was wrongfully convicted of a sexual assault in 1984 and a judge officially cleared Fears. He joined family members for a celebratory first meal in freedom and will now begin the arduous process of building a new life in a changed world.


Fears’ case was reviewed as part of a joint project between the Ohio Innocence Project and the Columbus Dispatch newspaper, but the investigation was stalled when prosecutors said they couldn’t find his evidence.


Fears’ luck changed, however, when Ohio Innocence Project client Robert McClendon was exonerated in Fears’ county in 2008. Franklin County prosecutor Ron O'Brien said the McClendon case left an impact on him, and he ordered a thorough review of all stored evidence. The review turned up evidence from Fears’ conviction, and O’Brien immediately ordered testing.


Read more about his case from the Ohio Innocence Project and the Columbus Dispatch.Fears is the 234th person exonerated by DNA testing nationwide, and the eighth in Ohio. Learn more about exonerations in your state here.


On the heels of the exonerations of McClendon and Fears, Ohio lawmakers are considering wide-ranging reforms to prevent injustice in the state. State Sen. David Goodman introduced a bill yesterday seeking improved access to DNA testing, a requirement to record all interrogations and reforms to eyewitness identification procedures.

Five to Go


From the Blog of The Innocence Project :


Five to Go


Posted: March 12, 2009 4:44 pm


Yesterday, South Dakota Gov. Mike Rounds signed a new law making his state the 45th in the country to explicitly grant access to post-conviction DNA testing to prisoners claiming innocence. Like many post-conviction DNA access laws around the country, however, South Dakota’s new law includes procedural hurdles that could make it difficult for some prisoners to get DNA testing.





The remaining states with no DNA access law are Alaska, Alabama, Massachusetts, Oklahoma and Mississippi.

Monday, 2 March 2009

WRONGFULLY INCARCERATED, RECENTLY EXONERATED BREVARD RESIDENT WILLIAM DILLON SPEAKS TO THE PUBLIC SATURDAY, MARCH 7, 2009


WRONGFULLY INCARCERATED, RECENTLY EXONERATED BREVARD RESIDENT WILLIAM DILLON SPEAKS TO THE PUBLIC SATURDAY, MARCH 7, 2009


in his first public address since release in November 2008


Brevard resident William Dillon, who served over 27 years for a crime he did not commit, will make his first address to the public since his exoneration in November 2008, joining the Innocence Project of Florida (IPF) on stage at the Gleason Center, Florida Tech campus, 6:00pm, Saturday, March 7, 2009 at the 5th Annual Progressive Celebration hosted by the Space Coast Progressive Alliance and co-sponsored by WFIT 89.5FM.


Dillon will join IPF Assistant Director Toni Shrewsbury during an award ceremony recognizing the work that IPF has done since their inception in 2003, resulting in the release of ten wrongfully incarcerated Floridians who, through DNA testing, were proven factually innocent of the crimes for which they were convicted. In addition to obtaining the freedom of these individuals, IPF's work has resulted in widespread recognition of the need to reform the state criminal justice system, where fundamental problems have been identified in the areas of eyewitness identification, false confessions, evidence preservation, crime lab oversight, access to DNA testing, and exoneree compensation. IPF has received over 2000 inquiries/requests for assistance in proving the innocence of individuals currently incarcerated.


Dillon's 27 years in jail represent the longest time served by any of the 232 individuals exonerated nationwide as a result of DNA test results. Dillon was exonerated when his innocence of a 1981 murder was proved by DNA evidence that came as a result of a 2007 motion filed by IPF and attorney Mike Pirolo. Dillon was subsequently released November 18, 2008.


The state's case against Dillon was based largely on the testimony of an admitted perjurer who had a sexual liaison with the case's lead investigator during the investigation, a fraudulent dog scent expert, a partially blind eyewitness and an individual whose own charges in a rape case were dropped in exchange for his testimony, which included numerous details at odds with known facts in the case.


Both Dillon and Shrewsbury will be joining Progressive Celebration attendees at a pre-event reception greeting Bob Edgar, President and CEO of Common Cause, a 400,000 member nonprofit, nonpartisan citizen lobby for reforms that make government at all levels more open, honest, and accountable, and re-engages citizens with civic responsibility. Edgar will then keynote the celebration with a talk addressing the challenges facing the Obama administration in meeting its promises for education, health care and energy policy. Edgar will specifically address key reforms that have taken hold in other states and how such reforms can be pursued in Florida. Celebration attendees will have the opportunity to question Edgar about Fair Districting, public campaign financing, and other fundamental reforms directed toward government accountability and the campaign/election process. Edgar's talk will follow a live music performance by Evan Greer, RiotFolk musician, performing original songs of citizen empowerment, sustainability and social justice. Concerned citizens of all ages are invited and urged to attend.


Doors open at 6pm to the event, which benefits both WFIT 89.5FM, a public radio station serving South Brevard and Indian River County, and the Space Coast Progressive Alliance, a local grassroots citizen lobby for progressive public policies.


Tickets are available from WFIT 89.5FM (321-674-8950 or http://www.wfit.org/).


###


EVENT INFO


5th Annual Progressive Celebration
an evening of inspiration and information
hosted by Space Coast Progressive Alliance
co-sponsored by WFIT 89.5 FM
Saturday, March 7, 2009 on campus, Florida Institute of Technology,150 W University Blvd, Melbourne FL 32901


5-6:30pm - Pre-event Party, Meet & Greet Reception in Hartley Room, Student Union Building. Limited attendance, tickets required.


6:00pm - Doors open at Gleason Performing Arts Center for Progressive Celebration


6:15pm - Live Music with Evan Greer, RiotFolk Music Collective


7:00pm - Welcome and Award Presentation to Innocence Project of Florida, followed by keynote speech by Bob Edgar, President & CEO of Common Cause


Presentation title: "The Audacity of Hope vs. Pay-to-Play Politics: Obama's Challenge
8:45pm - Edgar book signing, progressive information tabling, music resumes


Tickets available from WFIT (online at wfit.org or call 321-674-8950)


$20 advance / $25 at the door, if available
$10 students
$60 tickets


MEDIA welcome with press credentials/identity.



CONTACTS
ALL AVAILABLE FOR INTERVIEW


Innocence Project of Florida Assistant Director Toni Shrewsbury: 850-561-6767 or tshrewsbury@floridainnocence.org


Common Cause: Mary Boyle, VP Communications, via Mike Surrusco 202-736-5788 or msurrusco@commoncause.org, or John Briscoe, VP Development, 202-841-4507 or jbriscoe@commoncause.org


Common Cause Florida: Alex Chavez, 941-706-1877 or 941-737-1447, achavez@commoncause.org


Evan Greer, RiotFolk Musician: respectyourmama@gmail.com or evangreer@gmail.com or 978-852-6457


Local event co-chair: Cammie Donaldson, 321-917-1960 or cammiedonaldson@earthlink.net


Local event co-chair & pre-event reception chair: Susan Martin, 321-773-1276 or zulu2@cfl.rr.com
-----
Space Coast Progressive Alliance (SCPA) is a Florida nonprofit corporation supported by membership dues, donations, and event ticket sales. Nonpartisan by strongly progressive and politically active, SCPA encourages citizen engagement in the political process and seeks to advance progressive public policy at the local, state and national level.

Sunday, 1 March 2009

Prosecutors, Crime Victims and Exonerees File in Innocence Project Supreme Court Case




http://www.oranous.com/DNA/Osborne/exonerated.htm

http://www.oranous.com/DNA/Osborne/08-6_RespondentAmCuIndExoneratedbyDNATesting.pdf

From the Blog of The Innocence Project :

Prosecutors, Crime Victims and Exonerees File in Innocence Project Supreme Court Case

Posted: February 5, 2009 6:45 pm

Diverse voices from across the criminal justice system filed friend-of-the-court briefs this week urging the U.S. Supreme Court to recognize that the federal Constitution allows prisoners access to DNA testing that could prove their innocence. The Innocence Project represents an Alaska man who is seeking DNA testing that could prove his innocence; the Supreme Court will hear the case next month.
Among the individuals and groups filing on behalf of William Osborne were current and former prosecutors, who argue that the majority of prosecutors are willing to review cases where DNA testing could change a verdict – but that relying solely on the unfettered discretion of prosecutors can sanction injustice. A group of crime victims also filed a brief, including a woman who was raped by a man who remained at large while an innocent person was in prison for his previous crimes.
“These briefs reflect the growing consensus that everyone – prosecutors, defendants, crime victims, the government and society – has an interest in making sure people have access to DNA testing that can prove innocence,” said Peter Neufeld, Co-Director of the Innocence Project, which is affiliated with Cardozo School of Law. Neufeld will argue the case at the Supreme Court on March 2. “In the vast majority of cases, prisoners are granted DNA testing under state law or because prosecutors consent to testing without a court order. Alaska is the exception. It is the only state in the nation with no known case of a prisoner receiving DNA testing, either through court order or a prosecutor’s consent. This case involves a very important constitutional protection – one that is the only option for William Osborne.
Oral arguments in William Osborne’s case will be heard March 2.

Wednesday, 25 February 2009

Innocence Project of Florida Asks State Attorney to Test DNA in Case of Wayne Tompkins




Innocence Project of Florida, Inc.


1100 East Park Avenue,

Tallahassee, FL 32301

Telephone 850.561.6767

Fax 850.561.5077


For Immediate Release


February 25, 2009


Contacts: Seth Miller, Esq.:

202.341.2127


Innocence Project of Florida Asks State Attorney to Test DNA in Case of Wayne Tompkins

Serious Doubts Remain About the Guilt of a Florida Man Executed February 11


The Innocence Project of Florida today sent a letter to the Hillsborough County State Attorney’s Office asking for their help in answering lingering questions surrounding Wayne Tompkins’ guilt.“Though Mr. Tompkins’ case ended with his execution on February 11th,”wrote Seth Miller, Executive Director of the Innocence Project of Florida, “it remains an open question as to whether he committed this murder, and robust scientific means can and should be employed to answer that question.”


Mr. Tompkins was convicted of murdering his girlfriend’s daughter,Lisa DeCarr, in 1983. One year after Ms. DeCarr disappeared from her home, skeletal remains were found under her porch.


The identity of the body has remained an enduring question in the Tompkins case. Authorities identified the body as Lisa DeCarr’s based solely on the fact that Ms. DeCarr and the body both had a single occluded tooth. The Innocence Project of Florida called this method of identification “wholly unpersuasive” in a letter they wrote to Florida Governor Charlie Crist urging him to stay the execution. More troubling are the signed affidavits from several witnesses stating that they had seen or had contact with Ms. DeCarr since the date ofthe supposed murder.


Governor Crist stayed Mr. Tompkins’ execution in 2008 and ordered DNA testing on the bone fragments found under Ms. DeCarr’s porch. When those results came back inconclusive, Mr. Tompkins’ execution was reset.


Since his execution, there has been speculation that Lisa DeCarr’s killer also murdered another young woman, Jessie Albach. Because some in law enforcement believe the same person is responsible for both murders, DNA testing of any remaining physical evidence in the Albach case may shed light on Wayne Tompkins’ innocence of the DeCarr murder. IPF has requested that DNA testing be performed on remaining evidence in both the DeCarr and Albach cases.


The Innocence Project of Florida is hoping that the State Attorney’s Office wil agree to DNA testing at a private lab at IPF’s expense. Private laboratories, such as Forensic Science Associates in Richmond, California, are able to conduct advanced methods of evidence collection and DNA testing not currently performed at FDLE or FBI labs. Should testing demonstrate that the body did not belong to LisaDeCarr, Florida will become the first state scientifically shown to have executed an innocent man. This same State Attorney’s office had previously agreed to send biological evidence to Forensic Science Associates for DNA testing in the case of Alan Crotzer. Mr. Crozter was exonerated in 2006 after results of that testing proved his innocence of a 1981 rape.


Miller told the State Attorney’s Office, “It is our hope that you will again apply the same reasoned judgment to the instant case, agree that this is the course of action that justice requires, and work with the Innocence Project of Florida to ensure that appropriately swift action is taken to put to rest these remaining uncertainties.


”The Innocence Project of Florida is a 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to finding and freeing innocent people in Florida prisons. IPF consulted on the DNA issues in the case of Wayne Tompkins.

Wednesday, 18 February 2009

Murder conviction overturned after 14 years


Joshua Kezer, convicted in the 1992 murder of Angela Mischelle Lawless, who was found shot to death in her car. The murder case has been reopened by Scott County Sheriff Rick Walter.

Joshua Charles Kezer spent more than 14 years in prison for a murder that he insisted he didn't commit.

On Tuesday, Kezer was vindicated.

A Cole County judge overturned Kezer's conviction for second-degree murder and armed criminal action and affirmed Kezer's claim of actual innocence. The judge also concluded that the original prosecutor in the case, Kenny Hulshof, the former six-term Missouri congressman, withheld evidence.

"This is proof that God is real," Kezer said from prison. "This is proof. This is wonderful."


Kezer has been serving a 60-year sentence at the Jefferson City Correctional Center for the 1992 killing of Angela Mischelle Lawless, a 19-year-old college student. Lawless was found shot to death in her car just off Interstate 55 near Benton, Mo.

No physical evidence — DNA, fingerprints or murder weapon — linked Kezer to the crime. There were no eyewitnesses. Friends and family said Kezer was 350 miles away in Kankakee, Ill., on the night of the murder.


In a rare move by law enforcement, Scott County Sheriff Rick Walter reopened the closed murder case in 2006. The Post-Dispatch published a report in November 2007 about the Kezer case and Walter's suspicions that Lawless' killer was still at large. Kezer was granted an evidentiary hearing in December.

By then, the only prosecution witness to place Kezer near the murder scene had recanted. The defense also argued that prosecutors in the original case didn't provide several pieces of exculpatory evidence to Kezer's attorneys.

In ruling that Kezer's case meets the legal standard of actual innocence, Judge Richard Callahan concluded that no reasonable juror would convict the defendant in light of newly discovered facts. The judge ordered Kezer to be released from Jefferson City Correctional Center within 10 days unless Scott County Prosecutor Paul Boyd decides to retry him.

For now, Boyd's plans remain unclear. He did not return calls seeking comment.

"I can't imagine they could retry him on this case," said Charlie Weiss, one of the attorneys from the St. Louis law firm Bryan Cave who represented Kezer. "They have nothing. They have no physical evidence whatsoever, and the snitches have no credibility."

Kezer, now 34, is the 17th inmate to be exonerated in Missouri since 1982, according to the Midwestern Innocence Project, based in Kansas City.

"I've been laughing and crying since I heard the news," Kezer's mother, Joni Kezer said. "God is great. That's all we had to gone on. We never lost hope because we always had faith."

Lawless' brother, Jason, said that he was sickened to know that an innocent man was convicted for the murder of his little sister. "Mostly I just feel sorry for him, I really do," said Jason Lawless of Scott City. "He sat in there all this time for something he didn't do, which is horrible for him."

During the December hearing, defense attorneys presented witness testimony that the judge said undermined the case against Kezer:

— Chantelle Crider, who originally said she saw Kezer argue with the victim at a Halloween party one week before the murder, now says she was mistaken.

— Cape Girardeau Detective William Bohnert described a statement given to him by Mark Abbott, the only person to claim Kezer was near the crime scene. According to Bohnert, Abbott told him in 1997 that he saw one of his married friends shoot Lawless because of an affair he was having with her. Abbott is serving a 20-year sentence in federal prison for methamphetamine trafficking.

— Two southeast Missouri residents — Cathy Fowler and Ron Burton — said they heard Abbott and his friend boast about killing Lawless after the trial concluded in 1994.

In his 44-page ruling, the judge said Kezer was betrayed by almost every level of the judicial process.

"There is little about this case which recommends our criminal justice system," Callahan wrote. "The system failed in the investigative and charging stage, it failed at trial, it failed at the post trial review and it failed during the appellate process."

Hulshof, now an attorney at Polsinelli Shughart law firm in Kansas City, said in a statement Tuesday that he stands by Kezer's conviction.

"The jury came to a unanimous decision that Mr. Kezer's alibi witnesses were not credible and that the state had proven beyond a reasonable doubt," Hulshof said. "My biggest regret is that the family of Mischelle Lawless is experiencing a travesty of justice."

Callahan criticized Hulshof, who prosecuted the case for the attorney general's office, over issues of evidence. The judge said several pieces of evidence should have been made available to Kezer's original trial attorneys, including:

— A police report in which Mark Abbott named Ray Ring, not Joshua Kezer, as the driver of a white car he saw near the murder scene. A Scott County sheriff's detective found this report paper-clipped to the back of the original investigation file in 2007.

— A notebook kept by Scott County deputy Brenda Schiwitz was found by Walter during his investigation. The notebook showed that Mark Abbott had been considered a suspect early on, though Schiwitz testified at trial that Abbott was never a suspect and that she had destroyed her notes. Schiwitz gave a deposition in 2008 that she gave her notes to Hulshof and his investigator. Hulshof, the Republican nominee for governor who lost to Jay Nixon last year, did not address the judge's conclusion that evidence was withheld from the defense. He declined to be interviewed.

Callahan said there is a reasonable probability that the outcome of the trial would have been different if any of the withheld evidence had been disclosed to Kezer's defense. Sheriff Walter was the "only bright note" in the case, the judge added.

"Largely through (Walter's) efforts, along with those of petitioner's counsel, is the system finally righting itself with respect to Josh Kezer," Callahan wrote.

Contacted Tuesday, Walter said he believes the wrong man was put behind bars. "We never set out to free Josh," the sheriff said. "We set out to find out who the other killers were."

And that's why, Walter said, the Lawless murder case remains open.

(Source: www.stltoday.com)

Monday, 16 February 2009

Innocence Project of Florida Plans to Test Tompkins Evidence

Frank Lee Smith


Innocence Project of Florida,

Inc.1100 East Park Avenue, Tallahassee,

FL 32301

Telephone 850.561.6767

Fax 850.561.5077


For Immediate Release



PRESS RELEASE



February 16, 2009


Contacts:Seth Miller, Esq.: 202.341.2127


Innocence Project of Florida Plans to Test Tompkins Evidence

Tompkins could be First Ever Executed Man to be Proven Innocent


Today the Innocence Project of Florida (IPF) reiterated its intent to test the remaining DNA evidence in the case of Wayne Tompkins. Mr. Tompkins was executed on Wednesday, February 11th, in Raiford, Florida after being found guilty of murdering Lisa DeCarr in 1983. IPF believes that further testing in the case could reveal that the body did not belong to the alleged victim, meaning Mr. Tompkins had been convicted of a murder that did not take place.



“We have a remarkable case with Mr. Tompkins,” said Seth Miller, Executive Director of the Innocence Project of Florida. “The State supported this match between the body and the victim with a partial dental record, which was pretty unconvincing. But on top of that, several people have signed affidavits saying that they’ve seen her alive since the murder.



If that’s the case, then Florida just killed an innocent man.



”If it were found that Mr. Tompkins was innocent of the 1983 murder, it would be the first case in American history of an executed man being scientifically proven innocent posthumously. In 2000, Frank Lee Smith was exonerated by DNA testing 11 months after he died of cancer on Florida’s Death Row.



IPF sent a letter to Florida Governor Charlie Crist on Tuesday, February 10th, urging him to stay Tompkins’ execution. On the next day IPF filed a motion asking a judge to notify the appropriate authorities of their statutory obligation to preserve the evidence in Mr. Tompkins’ case for 60 days after his execution. The Thirteenth Circuit Court granted that motion the same day.



“These agencies need to know we’re serious about going forward with testing, and we want to make sure they are preserving all of the evidence pursuant to Florida law,” said Miller. “If the State Attorney is convinced that Mr. Tompkins was guilty, they should support testing to put the doubts to rest. We’ll pay for it, they just need to give us access to the evidence.”



“We look forward to working with the State Attorney’s Office to get the DNA testing,” added Miller. “We’re going to make sure we discover the truth in this case.”



The Innocence Project of Florida is a 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to finding and freeing innocent people in Florida prisons. IPF consulted on the DNA issues in the case of Wayne Tompkins.

Innocence Project of Florida

1100 East Park Ave

Tallahassee, FL

32301 US

Saturday, 14 February 2009

Wrongful Conviction event is in BIRMINGHAM


- Wrongful Conviction event is in BIRMINGHAM ---- UPDATED announcement with clarification TIME & PLACE

"It's difficult," says Watkins. "I still walk around the office gently because I know there are a lot of people who still don't want me here.

" But, he says, every time justice is done, we "restore credibility that law enforcement can work for everyone."

APRIL 4 (Sat) 7:00 - 8:30pm

Univ. of Alabama at BIRMINGHAM - Hill University Center

Alumni Auditorium


Panel Topics:

1. Making DNA evidence available to all convicted felons

2. "Convict at all Costs", what does that mean?

3. Should the legislature abolish judicial override

Event is open to the public


Panel discussion at UAB, sponsored by the Dept of Justice Sciences and the Justice Committee of the Universal Unitarian Church of Birmingham.

Panelists & Profiles:
1. Dallas Texas DA, Craig Watkins. (Elected 2006) - First African American to be elected, District Attorney in the state of Texas. http://www.dallasda.com/index.html
2. Jefferson County, Family Court Presiding Judge, Brian Huff - http://10jc.alacourt.gov/bh.html
3. Attorney, Richard Jaffe, Birmingham, AL - http://www.rjaffelaw.com/Bio/RichardJaffe.asp

Moderator:
Dr. John Sloan, III, Chair of the Dept of Justice Sciences, UAB
http://main.uab.edu/show.asp?durki=73267


Program Director:
Nancy Rhodes
Co-Chair, Justice Committee
Universal Unitarian Church, Birmingham, AL
205-415-0888
bsol2008@gmail.com



More Information on "Who is Craig Watkins":
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkdbZ6_jkcg


Special Guest: The Honorable Craig Watkins, Dallas Tx Dist Atty.

Internationally known for his unprecedented act of opening the prosecutor's office to the Texas Innocence Project for the purpose of undoing wrongful convictions.

Mr. Watkins' innovative strategies have garnered him local, national and international attention from CNN, ABC's "Good Morning America," German TV, Dallas Morning News, New York Times, Washington Post, L. A. Times and Chicago Tribune, to name a few.


Craig Watkins, a Dallas native, was inaugurated on January 1, 2007, as the Criminal District Attorney (DA) for Dallas County, Texas. He is the first African-American elected to that position in Texas. As DA for Dallas County, his "smart on crime" philosophy engages innovative strategies throughout the prosecutorial process and seeks to address the root causes of why offenders commit crime. DA Watkins' interest in conviction integrity led to partnering with the Innocence Project of Texas to aid the wrongfully convicted.

District Attorney Watkins was educated in the local public school system, received a Bachelor of Arts degree in political science from Prairie View A&M University and a Juris Doctorate degree from Texas Wesleyan University School of Law.

He is a member of Friendship-West Baptist Church, Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity Inc., Prairie View A&M University Alumni Association and is affiliated with several professional and civic organizations. Mr. Watkins has received numerous honors and awards for his outstanding accomplishments in the community from an array of organizations and groups.

Dallas Urban League Torch Award

  • One of Eclipse Magazine's "Super Lawyers" January 2007
  • District Attorney Watkins was featured in the March 5, 2007 issue of JET.
  • District Attorney Watkins was featured in the May 2007 issue of Ebony Magazine as one of THE EBONY POWER 150 as the next generation of African-American leaders.
  • Featured in the September 2007 issue of Texas Monthly
  • District Attorney Watkins' innovative strategies as the new DA in Dallas County have garnered him local, national and international attention from CNN, ABC's "Good Morning America," German TV, Dallas Morning News, New York Times, Washington Post, L. A. Times and Chicago Tribune, to name a few.

DA Watkins and wife Tanya have three children — Chad, Cale and Taryn.

Exoneration Man

November 2008 By JOHN BUNTIN | Photograph by Danny Turner

Most district attorneys make a name for themselves by winning convictions. Craig Watkins has done it by reversing convictions that never should have happened.

>> Craig Watkins, 39
>> District Attorney, Dallas County, Texas
>> Video: Watch Craig Watkins accept award
>> When he worked as a public defender, Watkins found that even the innocent felt pressured to plead guilty rather than take their chances before a jury. "That happened a lot," Watkins says. "It did such a disservice to the notion of justice."

From 1951 to 1987, the Dallas County district attorney's office was the domain of Henry Wade, a legendary prosecutor who personally never lost a case — and who rarely missed an opportunity to seek the maximum punishment for criminals. But in impoverished, predominantly African-American South Dallas, Wade's hardball tactics created resentment and distrust.

"Affluent people, people accepted by society, loved law enforcement. All of the other people who were economically disadvantaged, they didn't trust it — and I think rightly so," says Watkins. So in 2002, Watkins ran for D.A. Despite having no name recognition outside of South Dallas, Watkins came within 10,000 votes of winning. Four years later, he tried again and won, in the process becoming Texas's first elected African-American district attorney.

Watkins had a lot to prove. More than 200 of the 267 attorneys Watkins began managing had actively campaigned for his opponent because they didn't think Watkins had enough trial experience. At the same time, he believed he had a mandate to rectify past injustices. In February 2007, a mere one month after taking office, Watkins found himself face to face with a momentous decision.

The occasion was a court hearing for James Giles, who had spent 10 years in prison for a rape that subsequent DNA testing showed he did not commit. Giles was released. Afterwards, attorneys Barry Scheck and Jeff Blackburn — nonprofit leaders who work to free the wrongfully convicted from prison — presented Watkins with an unprecedented proposal. They volunteered to help Watkins' office review the files of more than 350 inmates, some dating back to as early as 1970, where physical evidence existed that could either confirm the inmate's guilt or establish his innocence.

A riskier step for a novice D.A. would be hard to imagine. Watkins agreed to it. That spring, he went to the Dallas County court of commissioners and won $450,000 to create a conviction-integrity unit to reinvestigate old cases. Since then, the unit has reviewed more than 180 case files, of which 21 have been flagged for DNA testing or further investigation. So far, a total of 19 Dallas County prisoners have been exonerated or freed. What Watkins has shown is that there's as much justice in clearing the names of the innocent as there is in putting the guilty behind bars.

"It's difficult," says Watkins. "I still walk around the office gently because I know there are a lot of people who still don't want me here." But, he says, every time justice is done, we "restore credibility that law enforcement can work for everyone."

Freed by DNA, man shares experience

Freed by DNA, man shares experience

The Daily Progress/Andrew Shurtleff

Marvin Lamont Anderson, the first person to be exonerated in Virginia after post-conviction DNA testing, speaks during the Virginia State Bar’s 39th aCriminal Law Seminar at the Doubletree Hotel.

By Tasha Kates

Published: February 14, 2009

By Tasha Kates

tkates@dailyprogress.com | 978-7265

As an 18-year-old in Hanover County, Marvin Lamont Anderson was living his life one fire call at a time.

Anderson was in training to be a firefighter in the early 1980s, but it will be next month before he finally graduates from the Hanover County Fire Academy.

It is a dream fulfilled for Anderson, albeit 26 years late. Falsely convicted of raping a woman in 1982 and sentenced to 210 years behind bars, he spent 15 years in prison and five years on parole before he was exonerated by DNA evidence.

Anderson, who is the first Virginian and the 99th person nationwide to be exonerated by DNA, shared some of his insights Friday at the Virginia State Bar’s 39th Annual Criminal Law Seminar. The event took place at the Doubletree Hotel Charlottesville.

“Usually, most people ask how did I survive,” Anderson said. “My mother. God and my mother. Why I’m not crazy, that’s a different story.”

Anderson, who said Friday was the first time he had addressed a group of lawyers and judges, said he typically tells law students that they should go into law with an open heart and remember that their clients are human beings. He gave the established lawyers a different task.

“As lawyers and judges, you have the opportunity to change the system,” Anderson said, “but you have to have it in your heart and mind to correct the system.”

Since he was exonerated, Anderson said he has seen some positive changes in Virginia. He cited the changes in the state’s “21-day rule,” which used to prevent judges from considering evidence submitted to the court if 21 days had passed after sentencing. Defendants who maintain their innocence now may present strong evidence, such as DNA, after that deadline.

David P. Baugh, chairman of the state bar’s Criminal Law Section, said Anderson’s story is a good reminder that clients often face long-term consequences.

“It doesn’t make sense to talk law to lawyers,” Baugh said. “They need to see the end product.”

Anderson shared a few pieces of advice with the crowd, including his grandmother’s reminder that “trouble is easy to get in, but hard to get out.” He told the audience that if he could be falsely convicted of a crime, so could they.

A few months before he was arrested, Anderson’s fire engine went to refuel after responding to a house fire. The refueling station was near the jail.

Anderson told the audience that he looked at the jail and said to his colleague, “That is one place I’d never be.”

He paused.

“Four months later, I was there.”

http://www.dailyprogress.com/cdp/news/local/article/freed_by_dna_man_tells_of_survival/35806/


Innocence Project of Florida Moves to Preserve Evidence in Tompkins’ Case

From the blog of the Innocence Project in Florida :


Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Innocence Project of Florida Moves to Preserve Evidence in Tompkins’ Case

For Immediate Release

Innocence Project of Florida Moves to Preserve Evidence in Tompkins’ Case

Says DNA TestingCould Reveal that Man Scheduled for Execution is Innocent of Murder


Today the Innocence Project of Florida (IPF) is filing a motion to preserve evidence in the case of Wayne Tompkins, who is scheduled to be executed at 6 PM EST by lethal injection.

Tompkins was convicted of murdering Lisa DeCarr in 1983, though doubts persist as to the true identity of the victim. IPF believes a new round of DNA testing should be conducted in order to banish all doubt, and today’s action represents the first step toward acquiring that testing.

“If the victim in this case wasn’t Lisa DeCarr after all, that means Wayne Tompkins was convicted of a murder that never took place. It’s pretty bizarre that the Governor is about to execute a person when these kinds of questions remain,” said Seth Miller, Executive Director of the Innocence Project of Florida. Several individuals have signed affidavits claiming to have seen DeCarr alive since the alleged murder.

“The Governor should remember two other cases, Frank Lee Smith and Ricky McGuinn,” said Miller. Frank Lee Smith died on death row in Florida before DNA testing proved he was innocent. In Ricky McGuinn’s case, his Texas execution was stayed, then DNA testing proved his guilt, and his execution was reset. In both cases, DNA testing proved vital to the establishment of culpability.

IPF is moving a court to notify the appropriate institutions that they have a statutory obligation to preserve all evidence pertaining to Tompkins’ case for 60 days, even if he should be executed. IPF wants a robe, a sash, and samples of the victim’s bones to be preserved, with confidence that a new round of DNA testing, using methods that have not been used in this case, will likely yield the identity of the victim.

Miller added, “There are serious doubts left in this case, and we fully intend to get to the bottom of what really happened. Tompkins shouldn’t be executed when such important questions as the identity of the victim remain. Some day soon, we will make sure the truth comes out.”

The Innocence Project of Florida is a 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to finding and freeing innocent people in Florida prisons.

IPF consulted on the DNA issues in the case of Wayne Tompkins.

# # #Download the press release here.

Visit IPF's Website here;

sign up to volunteer here;

contribute to our work here.

Wayne Tompkins was denied DNA testing and was killed innocent in Florida




You can read about the Wayne Tompkins case on the Florida blog here :




There is a chance that he will be exonerated by DNA posthumously.

Tuesday, 10 February 2009

Letter from Florida Innocence Project to Governor Crist - the case of Wayne Tompkins

Letter from Florida Innocence Project to Governor Crist - the case of Wayne Tompkins



The letter from Florida Innocence Project to Governor Crist - the case of Wayne Tompkins

http://www.oranous.com/innocence/WayneTompkins/crist_letter_tompkins_21009.pdf

Pressrelease from Florida Innocence Project - Wayne Tompkins

Pressrelease from Florida Innocence Project - Wayne Tompkins

http://floridainnocence.org/pdf/tompkins_release_21009.pdf

Innocence Project of Florida,
Inc.1100 East Park Avenue,
Tallahassee, FL 32301
Telephone 850.561.6767
Fax 850.561.5077

For Immediate Release
PRESS RELEASE

February 10, 2009

Contacts:Seth Miller, Esq.: 202.341.2127

Innocence Project of Florida Urges Governor to Stay Wayne Tompkins’ Execution
New Round of DNA Testing Could Answer Lingering Questions about Victim’s Identity

The Innocence Project of Florida (IPF), in a letter signed by their Executive Director Seth Miller, today urged Florida Governor Charlie Crist to stay the execution of Wayne Tompkins, who is scheduled to be killed on Wednesday by lethal injection. Serious doubts persist about the identity of the victim, and IPF believes a new round of DNA testing is likely to answer these important questions.

“We still harbor grave concerns about the legitimacy of Mr. Tompkins’ guilty verdict,” said Miller in his letter. “We feel strongly that more time is necessary to look into this case.”

Mr. Tompkins was found guilty of murdering Lisa DeCarr in 1983. The evidence against him was circumstantial and consisted of three witnesses, including one jailhouse snitch. The nature of this case is also uncommon because the identity of the victim herself is also in doubt.

The victim’s alleged identity was supported at trial by a comparison with dental records which Miller says was “wholly unpersuasive.” Since then, several individuals have signed affidavits claiming to have seen her alive since the murder.

“Because the dead body’s identity is an issue, [late last year] you ordered DNA testing on bones from that dead body as well as a robe and sash found with the dead body,” Miller wrote to Crist. “We presume you did so in order to remove any remaining questions about whether the State of Florida was about to execute an innocent man.” That round of testing came back inconclusive, says Miller. But he adds that,“the facts of the case have not changed. The uncertainty surrounding the identity of the alleged victim that led to the last round of DNA testing still exists. There should be clarity about the identity of the alleged victim before we execute a potentially innocent man. That clarity is obtainable in Mr. Tompkins’case.”

IPF believes that a new round of DNA testing, involving methods that have not yet been tried in this case, would likely yield results.

Miller pledged to work with Governor Crist to “answer these remaining questions and finally obtain closure in this case,” urging patience in order to avoid executing a potentially innocent man on Wednesday.

The Innocence Project of Florida is a 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to finding and freeing innocentpeople in Florida prisons.
IPF consulted on the DNA issues in the case of Wayne Tompkins.# # #