Tuesday, 5 August 2008

State moves to block doctor



Pathologist had been criticized for allegedly sloppy work, testimony against defendants later proven innocent

Jerry Mitchell • jmitchell@clarionledger.com • August 5, 2008


Counties no longer can hire Dr. Steven Hayne for their autopsies because Mississippi officials removed him Monday from a list of designated pathologists.

"It's high time," said Hinds County Assistant Public Defender Matthew Eichelberger, who has challenged Hayne's qualifications in court. "Our criminal justice system just took a gigantic leap forward. This is a proud day for Mississippi."

Critics have accused Hayne of sloppy work they say led to the imprisonment of the innocent.

On Monday, the Mississippi Department of Public Safety faxed a letter to Hayne informing him of his removal.

Hayne would not comment, but his attorney, former Jackson Mayor Dale Danks Jr., said the letter gave no reason for his removal. "I think it's totally unjustified and unfair, and this matter will probably wind up in litigation," he said.

A news conference is slated for 1:30 p.m. today for Public Safety Commissioner Steve Simpson to field questions on the matter. One question likely to be asked is how counties are going to fill the void left by Hayne, who has performed most of Mississippi's autopsies for more than a decade.

World-renowned pathologist Dr. Michael Baden of New York City said he believes getting rid of Hayne is a mistake. "Whatever the problems were, he's done a lot of work, and it's going to be hard to find the people to do the autopsies he was doing," he said.

Earlier this year, two Noxubee County men, Kennedy Brewer and Lavon Brooks, were proved innocent in the slayings of two 3-year-old girls. The two were freed after more than 15 years in prison.

Baden said those convictions relied mainly on the testimony of forensic dentist Dr. Michael West, not Hayne, who performed both autopsies. West testified there were bite marks on the girls and that Brewer and Brooks made those marks.

"Dr. Baden has said Mississippi would be in chaos if we didn't have Dr. Hayne," Danks said. "This is a man who works 20 hours a day to determine the cause and manner of death."

Hayne has said he performs 1,500 autopsies a year. The National Association of Medical Examiners has limited pathologists to fewer than 250 autopsies a year, but Hayne has said such a number is arbitrary and that others have done more than him.

He has said he works 110 hours a week, performing autopsies and testifying in court. He gets paid $550 per autopsy, which means he would gross about $825,000 a year from autopsies alone. But he has said he clears only up to $175 per autopsy because of expenses.

Since 1994, Mississippi has been without a state medical examiner, drawing criticism from the state medical association. This past session, lawmakers voted to give the medical examiner's office $500,000 in hopes of hiring a board-certified pathologist.

Defense lawyers have challenged Hayne's qualifications.

He has sworn under oath he is certified by the American Board of Forensic Pathology, which ceased to exist in 1995.

Hayne has compared that certification to receiving a degree from a university that was later shut down, saying that shouldn't negate his certification.

Experts say the gold standard for medical board certification in the United States comes through the American Board of Medical Specialties, which has 24 affiliate boards, including the American Board of Pathology. When physicians testify they are "board certified," they are referring to this, experts say.

This board certified Hayne in anatomical and clinical pathology, but he failed the exam for forensic pathology in 1989.

Hayne has said he angrily walked out because of a ludicrous exam question: "What color is most associated with death?"

Dr. Betsy Bennett, executive director of the American Board of Pathology, told The Clarion-Ledger there was no question on that exam remotely similar to Hayne's description.

Hayne has insisted Bennett is wrong, saying he would stake his entire reputation and career on it. He has said he is the victim of a witch hunt by the Innocence Project and other death penalty opponents. The Innocence Project worked to clear Brewer and Brooks.

Tucker Carrington, director of the Mississippi Innocence Project, said Hayne's removal "is a heartening development because I think to the extent that office is sending a message the status quo is no longer acceptable."

Hiring a state medical examiner would be a step in the right direction, he said. "Leaving it up to the prosecutors just hasn't been working."

The Hayne file

Name: Dr. Steven Hayne

Age: 66

Education, experience:

1976 — Graduate, School of Medicine, Brown University, Providence, R.I.

1976 — Internship, Letterman Army Medical Center, San Francisco

1976-80 — Residency, Letterman Army Medical Center, San Francisco

1980-83 — Chief, Department of Pathology, Munson Army Hospital, Fort Leavenworth, Kan.

1983-84 — Chief, Department of Pathology, Blanchefield Army Community Hospital, Fort Campbell, Ky.

1984-87 — Shoals Medical Laboratory, Sheffield, Ala.

1987-88 — Acting state medical examiner for Mississippi

1987-present — Pathologist, private practice


To comment on this story, call Jerry Mitchell at (601) 961-7064.

Sunday, 3 August 2008

Organization Says DNA Testing Demonstrates Inmate Is Innocent


THIS IS A MEDIA RELEASE FROM THE INNOCENCE PROJECT OF FLORIDA

DNA Testing Demonstrates William Dillon is Innocent

Dillon has Served Nearly 27 Years for a Murder he Did Not Commit; Attorneys Call for Immediate Release

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. -- On Monday, July 28, 2008, Orchid Cellmark, a nationally recognized forensic laboratory in Farmers Branch, Texas, issued a report in the case of State of Florida v. William Dillon, which demonstrates Dillon's actual innocence of the 1981 murder of James Dvorak in Canova Beach, Brevard County, Florida.

The court-ordered testing on DNA from the bloody yellow t-shirt worn by the murderer excludes William Dillon, confirming that someone other than Dillon murdered Dvorak. "After nearly 27 years in prison for a crime he didn't commit, the State should do the right thing and release this innocent man immediately," said Dillon's attorney, Mike Pirolo, Assistant Public Defender from the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit.

"This case has all of the hallmarks of a wrongful conviction," said Seth Miller, Executive Director of the Innocence Project of Florida, Inc. The State's evidence included subsequently recanted testimony of a star witness who was both threatened by and having sexual relations with one of the State's lead investigators; a mistaken eyewitness identification by a man legally blind in one eye; fraudulent scientific testimony of a dog handler who purported to link Dillon to the crime; and testimony of a jailhouse snitch whose pending rape charge was dismissed after naming Dillon as the murderer.

This case is eerily similar to that of Wilton Dedge, another man convicted in Brevard County and exonerated by DNA testing. In both cases, the State acted recklessly, using shockingly unreliable evidence to obtain and preserve convictions that the evidence clearly did not support. "With Dedge, the State dragged its feet for years before finally admitting they had the wrong man. I hope they've learned their lesson. The time to release Dillon is now," said Miller.

When informed of the results, Dillon said, "It makes me extremely happy that it's finally coming to an end. The results prove what I have said all along—I am innocent."

Wrongful conviction case hits new snag


BY JOE CARLSON jcarlson@nwitimes.com 219.933.3364 Tuesday, July 29, 2008



HAMMOND City officials want to pay $4.5 million to settle with a man they wrongfully imprisoned for 20 years, and the man wants to accept.

But federal judges are standing in the way, at least for now.

In 2006, Larry Mayes won a lawsuit he filed against the Hammond Police Department, which manipulated evidence to send Mayes to prison for a 1980 rape that modern DNA evidence now proves he did not commit.

Police officials admitted at trial that a detective on the case had used hypnotism on the victim of the attack to try to produce memories of her assailant, despite department policy against the unorthodox technique.

A federal jury awarded Mayes $9 million.

While the verdict was out on appeal, city officials and Mayes' attorneys agreed to settle the case out of court for $4.5 million -- but only if city officials floated a bond for the settlement and if federal judges agreed to invalidate the $9 million judgment.

The Hammond City Council approved the bond in April, but the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals has denied the request to throw out the jury award.

Many appeals courts across the country will automatically vacate an earlier court decision in order to promote settlements, but the Chicago-based 7th Circuit has refused, citing a concern about wasting judicial resources and other issues, U.S. Magistrate Judge Paul Cherry wrote.

"The parties do not have a settlement without the entry of an order vacating the jury verdict," Cherry wrote.

Hammond City Counsel Joseph O'Connor said the city wants the Mayes case erased from the court record before a similar case becomes and issue -- that of James T. Hill, who served 17 years in prison on the same 1980 rape and who also argues his DNA does not match samples recovered from the victim. City officials are expecting a lawsuit in that case based on court filings from Hill in Lake County court.

Despite the 7th Circuit's reluctance to invalidate the Mayes verdict, Cherry gave both sides until Aug. 8 to submit arguments regarding why the court should toss out a verdict that came after a two-week trial and "many hours of deliberation."

"I think it's just a small glitch, and it's going to be overcome. And this will be resolved," O'Connor said.

Woman On Death Row For 17 Years Now Could Be Released


DAYTONA BEACH, Fla. -- In a dramatic reversal Friday, a Daytona Beach woman once sent to death row for having her husband murdered had her life spared.

Prosecutors said Virginia Larzalere ordered her son to kill her husband for insurance money. She's been on death row for 17 years, but now she could be out of prison and on parole in just eight years.

Even the judge admitted time has changed the case. Original paperwork is lost, original witnesses are dead and the state had no choice but to give Larzalere her life.

After 17 years of fighting, prosecutors decided it wasn't worth pursuing the death penalty against Larzelere any longer.

"Since we had a locked in life in prison, it wasn't as if she was going to walk free," said assistant state attorney William Vose.

It was March 1991 when a masked murderer used a shotgun to kill Norm Larzelere in his Edgewater dental office. Virginia and her son Jason were arrested for the murder. The motive was millions of dollars in life insurance money. Jason was acquitted, but Virginia was not.

"Obviously, she was disappointed she didn't get a new trial also, because she's maintained her innocence from the beginning," said Larzelere's attorney Jim Valerino.

Her new sentence allows for the possibility though that, within eight years, she could be paroled. She told the judge Friday she doesn't accept it as the conclusion and a new attorney has already agreed to try proving her innocence.

Jason Lazelere was accused of being the masked gunmen in the murder and Virginia was in the dental office when it happened. Her new attorney says there is evidence the real killer was a robber from the Orlando area.

Study needed for Missouri death penalty


By JOE AMRINE
Special to The Star

Amrine A particularly important anniversary took place at the end of July: the day the state of Missouri admitted it nearly put an innocent man to death for a crime he did not commit.

I remember it vividly because I was there: I was the man who might have lost his life to our death penalty system.

For 17 years, I sat on Missouri’s death row, hoping and praying the truth would eventually set me free.

The only “evidence” used to convict me was the testimony of three men. Even after all three admitted they had lied, it took years for me to be released.

After what felt like several lifetimes, Missouri set me free in July 2003.

Five years after my exoneration, I wonder if Missouri can promise that another innocent person won’t face that lethal needle.

The evidence says “no”; we can’t make the basic guarantee that an innocent person won’t be convicted and sentenced to death.

I am counted along with 129 others all across our country and three from Missouri who have been sentenced to death, then exonerated. There are seven others who were wrongfully convicted in Missouri for crimes which DNA evidence proves they did not commit.

The DNA era has taught us that mistakes happen. We know now that eye-witness testimony, jailhouse informants or “snitches,” and even confessions do not always result in a proper conviction.

But what have we done to ensure that these potentially deadly mistakes aren’t made?

Missouri has never had a thorough examination of our death penalty system. The state set me free, acknowledging an innocent man had been in prison awaiting execution for nearly two decades.

Five years have passed, and still no study has been done to guarantee that another person won’t be set to die for a crime he did not commit. This baffles and horrifies me.

I have joined the Moratorium Now! campaign, which has organized hundreds of individuals, organizations, businesses, and faith groups demanding we examine our death penalty system.

Moratorium Now! seeks to learn how the death penalty affects Missourians. We want answers to such basic questions as:

•Does the death penalty deter murder?

•Does the death penalty help or hurt victims’ families?

•What does the death penalty cost Missouri taxpayers?

I know personally how important it is that we have answers to these fundamental questions. But this is an issue that every Missourian can care about.

The state can always set the innocent free; bringing the dead back to life is outside its capacity.


Joe Amrine lives in Kansas City.

Time to end the death penalty's cycle of violence


Texas’ death chamber is at the Walls Unit, in downtown Huntsville. The so-called Death House is at the far left of the building near the guard tower. Star-Telegram/Rodger Mallison



By RONALD CARLSON Special to the Star-Telegram


June 13, 1983, and Feb. 3, 1998, are two days that will forever be etched in my memory.

On that fateful day in June, I lost my dear sister, Deborah Thornton, senselessly murdered along with her friend Jerry Lynn Dean.

Fifteen years later, I witnessed another senseless act of violence: the execution of Karla Faye Tucker, the woman condemned for the crime.

Before I lost my sister, I had no opinion on the death penalty. But Deborah’s tragic death made the question of capital punishment a painfully personal one. When I learned of the murder of my only sibling, who had helped raise me after our mother died, I was filled with hatred. I would have killed those responsible with my own hands if given the opportunity.

But when I learned that those responsible — Karla Faye and her friend Daniel Garrett — were in fact facing death sentences, I was uncertain that justice was being served.

I’ve since had 25 years — almost half my life — to examine the subject, and the conclusion I’ve come to is a clear one: We as a society should not be involved in the practice of killing people.

Wanting to see those who killed your loved ones suffer the same fate is understandable — no one can sit in judgment of those who have faced such loss — but our justice system should not be dictated by vengeance. As a society, shouldn’t we be more civilized than the murderers we condemn?

Finding faith is what led me to this conviction and helped me confront my pain and anger.

Turning to God enabled me to realize that, while lashing out might satisfy our instinctual desire for revenge, we as a society must strive not to indulge those desires. Jesus preached the need to love one another and the sanctity of life — all life, no exceptions, no asterisks to the rule.

What could be a more egregious violation of his teachings than the state executing its own citizens in retribution?

The death penalty does nothing more than continue the cycle of violence that is corroding our society.

I have stood more than one time with Death Row families as they prepared to watch their loved ones head to the execution chamber. The pain that they feel is no different from the pain that I felt for my sister. When we engage in the practice of capital punishment, we force more people to suffer through the tragic loss I had to endure. We simply create more victims — victims of the very criminal justice system meant to protect us.

The broken nature of this system makes the practice of capital punishment all the more unconscionable. From inadequate counsel to the staggering number of wrongful convictions, it is morally deplorable to continue with the death penalty while these problems persist. Daniel died in prison before his execution could be carried out, but I was present at the execution of Karla Faye as a witness on her behalf. It was one of the most highly publicized executions in Texas history.

Karla Faye’s religious conversion while on Death Row had led many, including Pope John Paul II, to express support for clemency, but it was to no avail. Watching the execution left me with horror and emptiness, confirming what I had already come to realize: Capital punishment only continues the violence that has a powerful, corrosive effect on society.

While many advocated sparing Karla Faye’s life because of her redemption story, I consider myself an advocate for all life — and an opponent of all killing, whether it be the murder of innocent victims or the execution of the condemned.

As I watched Karla Faye die, all I could think was this: I can’t see Jesus pulling the switch.

Ronald Carlson lives in Houston and is an advocate against the death penalty.

Joe Amrine Speaks Out


By TChris, Section Death Penalty Posted on Sat Aug 02, 2008 at 10:40:36 PM EST



Joe Amrine spent 17 years on death row waiting to be executed for a crime he didn't commit. He writes on behalf of Moratorium Now!, a campaign to bring about a national moratorium on executions. Before advances in DNA technology began to demonstrate the shockingly significant risk that an innocent person will be put to death, Amrine knew that mistakes happen. He's lucky to be living proof of that fact.

We know now that eye-witness testimony, jailhouse informants or “snitches,” and even confessions do not always result in a proper conviction. But what have we done to ensure that these potentially deadly mistakes aren’t made?

Missouri has never had a thorough examination of our death penalty system. The state set me free, acknowledging an innocent man had been in prison awaiting execution for nearly two decades. Five years have passed, and still no study has been done to guarantee that another person won’t be set to die for a crime he did not commit. This baffles and horrifies me.

The last sentence in his essay is inarguable:
The state can always set the innocent free; bringing the dead back to life is outside its capacity.

Tuesday, 29 July 2008

Michael Mordenti

The Michael Mordenti case - summary available here:

http://www.michaelmordenti.us/

Sunday, 27 July 2008

Former Dartmouth resident, once on Florida death row, freed


By Brian Boyd
Standard-Times staff writer
July 26, 2008 6:00 AM


A Dartmouth native who spent 13 years on Florida's death row in a murder-for-hire case was released Friday after he agreed to a plea deal, his lawyer said.

Michael W. Mordenti, 67, was convicted in 1991 of killing Thelma Royston in Odessa, Fla., after the victim's husband allegedly sought to have her murdered for $10,000. First sentenced to death and later given life, Mr. Mordenti accepted a lesser charge of second-degree murder offered by the state after he won an appeal, his lawyer, Martin McClain, said.

His new sentence is 25 years, and he was ordered released immediately for time served plus good behavior, said Gretl Plessinger, a spokeswoman for the Florida Department of Corrections.

"This is a glorious day for me and my family," said his daughter, Michelle Bergeron, a New Bedford resident. "God has answered our prayers."

Mr. Mordenti, a former used-car dealer, grew up in Dartmouth. He and his third wife, Gail Milligan, sold a used-car lot on State Road in the early 1980s and moved to Florida, said Ms. Bergeron, who is the daughter of his second wife.

The victim's husband, Larry Royston, allegedly convinced Mr. Mordenti's ex-wife, Ms. Milligan, to arrange a hit on his wife. She said she contacted three people before getting her ex-husband to carry out the hit, the St. Petersburg Times reported. Mr. Royston committed suicide before his trial.

The Florida Supreme Court granted him a new trial in 2004 on grounds the prosecutors allegedly withheld evidence casting doubt on the credibility of his ex-wife, who was given immunity, the newspaper reported at the time of the court's decision.

However, following a second trial ending with a deadlocked jury, a third trial in 2005 resulted in Mr. Mordenti being convicted a second time and given life.

Earlier this year, an appellate court in Florida ordered a new trial, which was scheduled to start next month, due to evidence not admitted by the judge in the 2005 trial. Prosecutors offered second-degree murder, and Mr. Mordenti pleaded "in his best interest," without admitting guilt, Mr. McClain said in a telephone interview.

"He always maintained his innocence," said Ms. Bergeron, who praised his lawyers.

"It was very hard for my family through the years to go through this," she said.

It was not immediately clear what Mr. Mordenti would do next. Mr. McClain said he is considering moving to Alaska.

Contact Brian Boyd at bboyd@s-t.com

Inconsistency a given with death penalty

Dale Leo Bishop


By Tim Kalich
Editor



Saturday, July 26, 2008 9:15 PM CDT



Mississippi has been averaging an execution a year for the past six years — enough that we’re starting to grow somewhat numb to them.

We’ve come to expect the last-minute flurry of legal appeals, the countdown in the press, the pro and con vigils outside the gates of Parchman or at the Governor’s Mansion, and the deaf ear of whoever is governor for clemency.

And when the deed is done — when the lethal chemical mixture is injected into the arm of the condemned inmate — the show closes down until the string runs out for the next one on death row.

Mississippi is a pro-capital-punishment state. By margins of 3-to-1, maybe more, citizens here believe in an eye-for-an-eye. Their major complaint with executions is that they don’t happen often enough. Even the fact that at least 16 innocent inmates, including one in Mississippi, served time on death row but were later exonerated doesn’t seem to quench support for the ultimate punishment.

It’s unlikely that Dale Leo Bishop’s execution this past week will change public attitudes much. Bishop was guilty of the crime for which he convicted. He never pretended otherwise.

Still, his case exposes another troubling aspect of capital punishment having nothing to do with guilt and innocence. Rather, it demonstrates the arbitrariness of the death penalty.

Bishop, as has been amply pointed out, got a worse deal as an accomplice to a murder than did the associate who actually dealt the death blows.

Bishop, who is mentally ill, was his own worst enemy at his sentencing eight years ago. He waived his right to a jury’s determination of his punishment and asked to be executed. The presiding judge complied. The co-defendant who admitted to the gruesome bludgeoning went on trial later and drew a life sentence.

When Bishop got stabilized with medication, he tried to recount his death wish. He acknowledged his culpability in the murder of his former buddy Marcus Gentry, and he expressed remorse for his actions. He did not expect Gentry’s family to forgive him, but he decided that he would like to live after all. The appeals courts repeatedly turned him down.

So did Gov. Haley Barbour.

Now Barbour is taking grief not because he showed no mercy for Bishop, but because he did for another killer, Michael David Graham.

Days before Bishop’s execution, Barbour suspended Graham’s life sentence. Graham’s crime was just as dastardly — gunning down his ex-wife in broad daylight on a public street while she sat in her car. But Barbour, who got to know Graham as a trusty in the Governor’s Mansion, decided 19 years in incarceration was punishment enough.

Barbour and his spokespersons have been unconvincing in explaining the governor’s disparate judgment. They claim there’s no comparison between the the cases of Graham and Bishop.

The only real difference, though, is that Barbour had the opportunity to get to know one of the two men. Would Barbour’s response to Bishop’s request for clemency been different had Bishop been serving the governor eggs every morning rather than languishing on death row?

That’s what happens to those who take a hard line on capital punishment. It’s hard to extricate themselves from it later.

The Clarion-Ledger put itself into a similar bind. For years, the Jackson newspaper has editorialized in favor of capital punishment. It has complained about the lengthy delays, periodically showing the faces of every inmate on death row and how long their appeals have dragged out.

Last week, however, the Jackson newspaper argued in vain for clemency for Bishop. It said it was unjust to execute an accomplice to murder while letting the actual murderer’s life to be spared.

Later, in comparing Bishop’s fate to that of Graham, it bemoaned the apparent inequity. “If the law is not consistent, that is, equal for one as the other, it’s not justice,” the paper wrote.

That’s a commendable ideal, but it ignores the realities of the criminal justice system — and human nature for that matter.

There is no consistency in the criminal justice system. There are guidelines, of course, for the judges and juries to follow. Within the guidelines, however, there is a lot of room for humans on the bench and in the jury box to apply their sense of fairness or to be influenced by their own biases.

There will always be arguments about disparate verdicts and punishments. That’s because criminal trials are not and never will be flawless. As a rule, rich defendants do better than poor. White defendants do better than minorities. Sane defendants do better than the mentally ill. Even when all these factors are equalized, a defendant’s fate hinges heavily on the venue of his trial.

Bishop drew a death sentence from a judge who went by the book. A judge in another county might have seen Bishop’s death wish for the craziness it was and ordered a mental evaluation.

There are going to be inequities with every punishment. That’s a given. With the death penalty, though, the inequity is irreversible.

Saturday, 26 July 2008

THE LAST WORD

To: Fellow Anti-Death Penalty Bloggers, NACDL/TTLA/TCDLA/ ATLA Members and Law Faculty

Re: Rhode Island and West Hollywood International Film Festivals

During the last few years DNA evidence has cleared 400+ condemned prisoners in the United States. This irrefutable scientific evidence has caused many Americans to consider the probability that the “system” has been executing the innocent.

The Last Word is the first documentary to dig deeper than exoneration and prove beyond any doubt a case of wrongful execution. Most scholars, attorneys, religious leaders and politicians agree that proving a wrongful execution is the most important step toward slowing if not banning capital punishment.

The Last Word is not only dramatically captivating but also possesses high educational and motivational value for Americans (potential jurors) who presently support the death penalty. Through interviews and investigation this documentary unravels the complexity of our criminal justice system and demonstrates how we (society) built and continue to perpetuate a seriously flawed “machine” void of constitutionally guaranteed safety nets for the innocent. Equally inspirational is the film’s powerful message to Christians who have been misled by extremists to misinterpret the Bible as supportive of the death penalty.

The purpose of this email is to request your help by spreading the word about The Last Word (e.g. festival attendance; public screenings; classroom instruction; email forwards; home/church discussion groups; online chatter; etc.)

The film is currently weaving across America on the film festival circuit. DVD copies are available at thelastworddocumentary.com and Amazon.com. Educational and library distribution is being handled by National Film Network- - nationalfilmnetwork.com.

EXECUTIONS FOR JULY/AUGUST
Click here to view details on seven executions scheduled in Texas within the next few weeks!


REVIEWS
“Unique, intriguing and dramatic as it leads to a heart breaking conclusion. One of America’s greatest miscarriages of justice!”
Millard FarmerDeath Row AttorneyAtlanta, GA
[Mr. Farmer was Louisiana Death Row inmate Patrick Sonnier’s appellate attorney. Sean Penn portrayed Mr. Sonnier in Dead Man Walking.]

“A must see for every Christian who has an opinion about capital punishment.”
Bishop Emeritus Leroy Matthieson

“This film should be required viewing for every high school and college student in America.”
Bonita GundenUnited States Public Defender

“A perfect example of how lazy lawyers, crooked politicians and asinine laws caused the system to fail. In Garrett’s case, the match got thrown early on. His own lawyers threw the case!”
Jeff BlackburnTexas Director,The Innocence Project

“Had I known then what I know now I never would have voted to convict the boy. He’d still be alive today. We trusted in the doctors and the lawyers and the system. Unfortunately, we trusted too much.”
Nathan Shackleford Juror #12

“Powerful! Eye opening and informative. The Last Word is a valuable educational resource which will inspire my students in many ways.”
Claudia StuartProfessor Criminal JusticeTexas A&M University

“I’ve watched the film (three times) and enjoyed it immensely!”
Aaron PhillipsTravel & Entertainment Reporter Amarillo Globe News

MEDIA ANNOUNCEMENT
Attorney and Documentarian Jesse Quackenbush has been notified that his feature documentary, The Last Word is an “Official Selection” of the West Hollywood and Rhode Island International Film Festivals.

According to Quackenbush The Last Word has been recognized as the first documentary in America to establish convincingly that a criminally accused man has been executed for a crime he didn’t commit. The film re-examines the case of Johnny Frank Garrett, a mentally retarded teenage boy who was arrested, convicted and ultimately executed for the rape, mutilation and murder of a 76 year old nun on Halloween night 1981. Sister Tadea Benz was brutally attacked as she slept in her room at the St. Francis Convent in Amarillo, Texas.

Garrett claimed his innocence from the moment of his arrest until his dying breath. DNA evidence and admissions from the actual killer are revealed for the first time in the film. Adding a twist of horror, this documentary also reveals a curse Garrett cast on those responsible for his murder. The curse was written by Garrett in his final letter to “society.” The untimely and sometimes violent deaths of 20 people directly associated with Garrett’s case (including 5 suicides, 6 freak accidents and 7 rare cancers) are documented in the film. Quackenbush, who served as the films Writer, Director and Producer believes “the curse” is real and provides his reasons in Producer Comments at the film’s website.

The Last Word previously premiered at the Buffalo and Seattle International Film Festivals. The film is also an “Official Selection” at the Scottsdale & Eugene International Film Festivals in October. Discounted educational distribution is provided through National Film Network. DVD copies of the film are available through Amazon.com or at http://www.thelastworddocumentary.com/.

Contact Info: Cinco Rosas Productions 512-963-0475

NEWS COVERAGE FROM DEATH ROW
The next victim of the Texas “Death Machine” will be Larry Donell Davis, scheduled for execution on July 31, 2008. I was actually present at Mr. Davis’ trial in Amarillo when his Prosecutor committed an egregious mistake jeopardizing Mr. Davis’ chance for a fair trial. The Prosecutor, during closing argument, stalked over to Mr. Davis who was seated at counsel table and screamed “How can you find for this man who sits . . . silently . . . hiding behind his lawyer!”

This was a direct attack on Mr. Davis’ 5th Amendment right to remain silent and not have his silence counted against him. I testified at the Motion for New Trial about the reaction from three of the jurors, ranging from nodding heads of approval to gasps for air. The jury was clearly affected by the Prosecutor’s actions. The hang-em-high Judge, Sam Kaiser denied the Motion for New Trial in spite of his in chambers oral admonishment to the Prosecutor for potentially causing reversible error. I will learn soon if Mr. Davis has placed me on his witness list. If he decides to have me, I will attend and witness my first execution. I am also hoping to film Mr. Davis’ family as they prepare for and experience the execution. I hope to bring their misery to viewers in a future project.
Jesse QuackenbushDirector, The Last Word

FESTIVAL DETAILS
The Last Word is an "Official Selection" of the following upcoming film festivals.
West Hollywood International Film Festival Regency Theatre 7907 Beverly Blvd. Los Angeles, CA 90048 July 29, 2008 @ 2:30 p.m. website Rhode Island International Film Festival Bell Street Chapel 5 Bell Street Providence, RI 02903 August 10, 2008 @ noon website Eugene International Film Festival October 3-5, 2008 website
Scottsdale International Film Festival October 3-7, 2008 website
The Last Word has participated in the following film festivals in 2008.
Buffalo Film Festival Seattle International Film Festival

QUICK FACTS

Legality
1. Is the Death Penalty Legal in the United States?
After being suspended in 1972 because of a lack of national standards, the death penalty was declared constitutional (legal) again in 1976 with the provision that rigid statutes be used as a guide. Each state determines whether to permit the sentence of the death penalty. Thirty-six states currently have the death penalty. New Jersey became the first state in 40 years to abolish the death penalty in 2007. (DPIC)

2. Is it legal to execute juveniles or the mentally ill in the United States?
The Supreme Court struck down the death penalty for juveniles in 2005 and declared it illegal to execute defendants with mental retardation in 2002. (DPIC)

3. Is the Supreme Court currently considering the legality of the death penalty?
No, the Supreme Court is currently considering a very specific issue of whether the “3-drug cocktail” method of lethal injection constitutes “cruel and unusual punishment” and would thus be unconstitutional. The Court held a hearing in January 2008 and is expected to make a ruling in spring 2008. (DPIC)

4. What is a moratorium?
A moratorium is a halt on executions for a certain time period. During a moratorium, detailed examinations of capital punishment laws and processes can take place. In a 2007 opinion poll by RT Strategies, 58% of respondents believed it was time for a moratorium on the death penalty, many of those supporting a moratorium also being supporters of the death penalty. (DPIC)

Death Row Executions
5. How many inmates are on Death Row?
In 2008 there are 3,263 inmates on Death Row, with the largest rows in California (609), Florida (388) and Texas (370). (DPIC)

6. How many people have been executed in the United States?
There have been 1,099 executions in the US since 1976, with a peak in 1999 of 98 executions. The largest number of executions since 1976, 405, took place in Texas, with 26 of those occurring in 2007. (DPIC)

7. What countries are responsible for the most executions worldwide?
In 2006 91% of all known executions took place in six countries: China (1,010), Iran (177), Pakistan (82), Iraq (65+), Sudan (65+), U.S. (53). American and Japan are the only post- industrial nations that impose the death penalty. (DPIC)

8. Don’t most people in the U.S. support the Death Penalty?
The percentage of Americans in support of the death penalty peaked in the mid-1990s. According to Pew Research Center surveys, support for the death penalty for persons convicted of murder has fluctuated within a relatively narrow range of 62% of 68% since 2001, while opposition has ranged from 24% to 32% during this time. A Pew survey from August 2007 finds that 62% of Americans favor the death penalty, while 32% oppose it and 6% are unsure. (DPIC)
9. How much does the death penalty cost tax payers?

According to the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty, the estimated cost of single death penalty cases from arrest to execution ranges from $1 to $3 million, compared to an estimated cost of life imprisonment, including incarceration cost of $500,000. The estimated average cost of a death penalty case in TX, according to The Dallas Morning News is $2.3 million. (DPIC)

Methods
10. What methods of execution are currently used in the United States?
36 of the states with the death penalty use lethal injection for executions. In 2008 Nebraska, the only state that used the electric chair as the exclusive form of execution, outlawed the use of the electric chair. Some states utilizing lethal injection have other methods available as back-ups. (DPIC)

11. What is the “3-drug cocktail”?
A form of execution by lethal injection that involves three separate injections. The inmate is injected with sodium thiopental – an anesthetic, which puts the inmate to sleep. Next flows pavulon or pancuronium bromide, which paralyzes the entire muscle system and stops the inmate’s breathing. Finally, the flow of potassium chloride stops the heart. Death results from anesthetic overdose and respiratory and cardiac arrest while the condemned person is unconscious. (DPIC)

Wrongful Convictions and Exonerations
12. How many people have been released from death row?
Since 1973 over 120 people were released from death row with evidence of their innocence. From 1973-1999, there was an average of 3.1 exonerations per year. From 2000- 2007, there has been an average of 5 exonerations per year. (DPIC)

13. Is there any proof that an innocent person has been executed?
Until now, there has never been "uncontroverted proof" that an innocent person has been executed. No forum or legal standard exists for establishing such proof. However there is considerable evidence that other innocent persons have been executed. Cameron Willingham, executed in 2004 in Texas, is one such case. After examining evidence from Willingham’s prosecution, four national arson experts concluded that fire that Willingham was convicted of starting, was accidental. There are many other cases where significant doubts about guilt arose after a person’s execution, such as the case of Carlos DeLuna.

14. Do Americans believe those killed are guilty?
Three-quarters of Americans believe that an innocent person has been executed within recent years and that convictions is resulting in lower levels of support for the death penalty, according to a 2005 study by the University of Cincinnati and Radford University. When life in prison without the possibility of parole was offered as an alternative sentence for capital murder, less than half of all Americans who believe an innocent person has been executed supported the death penalty.

Religion
15. Do most Christians support the death penalty?
Some of the most recent data focusing on religion and the death penalty has looked at the views of Christians, a group that comprises over three quarters of the American population. According to a 2004 Gallop Poll, individuals who self-identify as Protestants are somewhat more likely to endorse capital punishment that are Catholics and far more likely than those with no religious preference. The poll found that more than 7 of 10 Protestants (71%) support the death penalty, while 66% of Catholics support it and that 57% of those with no religious preference favor the death penalty for murder. A 2005 Zogby poll revealed that only 48% of Catholics now support the death penalty. A recent poll by NationalChristianPoll.com found that two thirds of active Christians who oppose the death penalty are concerned about judicial error that could lead to an innocent person being executed. The poll also found that of Christians who support the death penalty, 60% do so because of biblical teachings. According to a 2007 Pew Forum poll, the strongest supporters of the death penalty are white evangelicals, with 74% approval.
16. What are the official stances of religious organizations on the death penalty?

According to the American Friends Service Committee’s Criminal Justice Program, which maintains a list of faith and ethical group that are opposed to the death penalty, many groups are officially opposed to capital punishment, including American Baptists, American Ethical Union, American Friends Service Committee, America Jewish Committee, The Bruderhof Communities, Central Conference of American Rabbis, Disciples of Christ, Church of the Brethren, Church Women United, Episcopal Church, Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, Fellowship of Reconciliation, Friends Committee on National Legislation, Friends United Meeting, General Conference of General Baptists, General Conference of Mennonite Church, Mennonite Church, Moravian Church in America, Orthodox Church in America, Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), The Rabbinical Assembly, Reformed Church in America, Reorganized Church, Union of American Hebrew Congregations, Unitarian Universalist Association, United Church of Christ, United Methodist Church, and the United States Catholic Conference. The Southern Baptists and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints have not taken a public position on the issue of capital punishment. The Qur’an supports the death penalty, but there is a strong tradition of mercy within the faith.

ANTI-DEATH PENALTY LINKS
Texas Moratorium Networkwebsite email
Texas Students Against the Death Penaltywebsite email
Lamp of Hope Projectwebsite email
Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penaltywebsite email
The Death Penalty Information Centerwebsite email
The Advocates for Human Rightswebsite email
Citizens United for Alternative to the Death Penalty (CUADP)website email
Ohioans to Stop Execution (OTSE)website email
National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty (NCADP)website email
Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penaltywebsite email
Fight the Death Penalty in USAwebsite email
Catholics Against Capital Punishment (CACP)website email
Catholic Campaign to End the Use of the Death Penaltywebsite email
Wisconsin Coalition Against the Death Penalty (WCADP)website email
Campaign to End the Death Penaltywebsite email
Coloradans Against the Death Penaltywebsite email
The Moratorium Campaignwebsite email
New Yorkers Against the Death Penaltywebsite email
The Oklahoma Coalition to Abolish the Death Penaltywebsite email
Virginians for Alternatives to the Death Penaltywebsite email
United States Against the Death Penaltywebsite email
The Peace Farmwebsite email
New England Death Penaltywebsite email

NEXT MONTH
Interviews from Texas' Death Row.
Condemned prisoners facing imminent execution share their "Last Words" and thoughts each month.

Mississippi Innocence Project Contributes to Exonerations


Newswise — Of the 18 years Levon Brooks spent wrongfully imprisoned at Parchman Penitentiary, three days were easy.

In March, an attorney called with news that sent Brooks' mind reeling. DNA evidence had proven what he and others had known since his arrest: He was innocent. After more than 6,000 days locked up without tangible hope of justice, a mere three days stood between Brooks and freedom. He used those days to make a list – a freedom list, a mental list of what he missed most.

"I couldn't begin to tell you all of the things on that list," Brooks said, with the grin that has seldom left his face since he was freed. "Seeing my mom, eating fish, going fishing, seeing my friends – so many things."

Brooks and Kenny Brewer, both of Noxubee County, are the first prisoners exonerated in Mississippi based on post-conviction DNA testing. Brooks was convicted in 1992 for the capital rape and murder of a 3-year-old girl. Brewer was convicted in 1995 of a remarkably similar crime in the same community less than 18 months after the murder for which Brooks was convicted. Interestingly, Brooks and Brewer knew each other growing up, and both know the man charged with both murders.

Their freedom is due to the work of the National Innocence Project in New York and the Mississippi Innocence Project, established last year at the University of Mississippi School of Law.

Work on Brewer's case began after a call from one of his attorneys, NIP co-founder Peter Neufeld said. At the same time, organizers started talking with author and UM law alumnus John Grisham, who had just joined the NIP board, about the need for an innocence project in Mississippi.

"The truth is, you can only do so much from 1,000 miles away," Neufeld explained. "It really takes people on the ground in each state to make a difference. It's really remarkable that in such a short time, the Mississippi Innocence Project got itself started, got students interested, got the backing of the university and other lawyers in the state, and, within a very, very brief time, pulled off a very important exoneration here in the state."

The Mississippi project was created with funding from Grisham and attorney Wilbur Colom of Columbus. In fall 2007, Grisham joined fellow author Scott Turow at a dinner to raise operating funds for the state organization.

"There has been very little innocence activity in Mississippi," Grisham said. "Our state has a high rate of wrongful convictions, literally hundreds of innocent prisoners behind bars. These people are serving time for crimes committed by others, and in many cases the real criminals are still breaking the law.

"There is a lot of work to be done, and the best place to start is in the law schools. The successful innocence projects are those based on campuses where there are student interns and dedicated faculty. It's a great opportunity for students, one I wish I had 30 years ago at Ole Miss."

Housed at the UM School of Law, the MIP includes a clinical program for students and is investigating more than 80 cases around the state. The Brooks and Brewer cases were the first for the new state project, which is not officially tied to the national organization.

"The two students assigned to Mr. Brooks' case were tremendous," said MIP Director Tucker Carrington. "They had been working on his case for a few weeks when they got word that the DNA tests and arrest of the perpetrator had absolved him. They set to work, and in two days' time drafted a pleading that we eventually filed in the Mississippi Supreme Court for Mr. Brooks' release."

The students help not only the organization but also themselves, he added.

"The students are a huge help during the year; they read applications, investigate cases, travel and visit clients in prison," he said. "What's more, they take with them a number of experiences, not the least of which is that the status quo treatment of indigent criminal defendants in this state is often a shameful and embarrassing fact that does so much damage to so many people. I don't think they're going to countenance it in their profession once they leave the law school."

Krystal Walker, a third-year law student from Louisville who worked on the Brooks case, was at the courthouse in Macon when he was released. She and other students talked to Brooks on the courthouse steps as he experienced his first few minutes of freedom.

"It is very fulfilling to know that what we did had a dramatic impact on Levon Brooks' life," she said. "When we went to court and met him, he thanked us. I wanted to thank him for letting me know that hard work pays off and it makes a difference. It is almost indescribable how I felt."

Whether the law students involved in more than 30 innocence projects across the country become divorce lawyers or tax attorneys, working on innocence cases helps shape them, Neufeld said.

"I've been doing this now for 17 years, and I can tell you I have never gotten tired of walking into a prison and taking someone by the hand and walking them into the light of day," he said. "There is one thing I know for sure, (the UM students) had a life-changing experience on the courthouse steps in Macon, Mississippi, and it will affect how they conduct themselves as lawyers and the way they live their lives as human beings until the day they die."

Still, there is a bittersweet aspect of the exonerations.

"There is nothing special about those cases. They weren't movie stars or athletes that someone set out to get. They are just regular people," Neufeld said. "What that tells you is that the same causes of their wrongful convictions are happening every day all across the country for other simple folk – common folk – who don't have the money to get good forensic testing or experts. So, it makes our job much more challenging, but of course much more essential. As soon as we possibly can, we have to wake up the nation to the causes of wrongful conviction and begin to remedy it."

That is why the MIP strives for meaningful criminal justice reform, said Carrington, who came to Ole Miss from Georgetown Law School in Washington, where he also served as a public defender.

"Our office endeavors to be a leader, whether it is representing clients with viable claims of innocence or legislative initiatives," Carrington said. "The facts of the Brooks and Brewer cases speak for themselves. They are emblematic of sloppy law enforcement, questionable forensic science and the perils of the state's lack of DNA preservation and testing legislation."

Because of problems surrounding the testimony of the two forensic witnesses in both the Brooks and Brewer cases, the state and national innocence organizations are working together to investigate the possibility of similar fraud in other cases in which those witnesses testified.

In July, state Attorney General Jim Hood formed a task force to study the financial needs of the state medical examiner's office and Mississippi Crime Lab. Mississippi has not had an official medical examiner since 1995, and the Crime Lab has been unable to hire enough DNA analysts because of inadequate funding.

Coupled with the subsequent arrest of a single suspect in the Brooks and Brewer cases, these investigations highlight the need for the MIP.

"It's not just about civil rights," Neufeld said. "In 82 of the exonerations the Innocence Project has worked on, the real perpetrator was identified. Those 82 people alone committed a few hundred rapes and murders from the time the wrong guy was convicted to the time that the real criminal was identified."

The families of the innocent become victims as well. The 15 years Brewer's mother spent without her son were extremely difficult. Confined to a wheelchair with medical problems related to diabetes, Brewer broke down as she recalled the shock and sadness she felt when Kenny was convicted.

"I prayed through it," she said. "I prayed for God to send him home. I prayed, 'Don't let him be electrocuted for something he didn't do.'"

Brewer works at a local food production company and is adjusting to living at home. On death row, he stayed in his cell 23 hours a day, with an hour for exercise.

"I stayed locked up for 15 years for nothing," he said. "They can't give that time back to me."

Brewer describes his goals since being exonerated as "what any man wants: to own a house and a vehicle, to have that type of life."

As for Brooks, he has spent the past few months crossing items off that list that he created during the three-day wait for freedom.

"First thing I ate was three plates of fried fish," he said. "I couldn't get enough. I got one, then another and another. All I wanted was fish."

Since that first fish fry, he has been fishing almost every day. He has spent a lot of time with his mother, whose health is failing. He's also dabbled in art, one of his goals before being incarcerated.

Using a variety of intricate techniques, Brooks creates one-of-a-kind greeting cards using detailed ink drawings shaded with colored pencils. The art kept him focused while he was locked up, and he hopes it will provide some income now that he is free.

Beneficiaries of a growing movement, Brewer and Brooks are among 220 people who have been exonerated through post-conviction DNA testing in the past 17 years, Neufeld said.

"What's happened is that we started with one project and two people," he said. "We now have more than 30 projects around the country with hundreds of law students and law professors involved. We have journalism students. We have projects in half-a-dozen other countries. What this has become is a burgeoning civil rights movement – the innocence movement."

For more information on the Mississippi Innocence Project, go to http://www.mississippiinnocence.org/




Libraries Life News (Law and Public Policy)

Keywords

INNOCENCE EXONERATION DNA EVIDENCE PRISONERS CONVICTIONS
Contact

Information

Available for logged-in reporters only
Description

In less than a year, the National Innocence Project and the Mississippi Innocence Project have secured the release of two Mississippi prisoners who were wrongly convicted. Levon Brooks spent 18 years locked up for murder, and Kenny Brewer was in prison 15 years for a similar crime, but both men were freed when DNA testing cleared them of the crimes. The exonerations spotlight a pressing need for innocence work nationwide.

Brainstorming to end injustice in Wisconsin


Exonerees, attorneys and community activists will come together Saturday in Milwaukee to discuss the causes of wrongful conviction and proposed reforms in the state to prevent future injustice. Panelists will include Chris Ochoa, who served nearly 12 years in Texas prison before DNA tests proved his innocence. Ochoa, who was represented on appeal by the Wisconsin Innocence Project, now lives in Madison and works as an attorney.


Wisconsin Innocence Project Co-Director John Pray said Wisconsin has made progress on addressing the causes of wrongful convictions, but still has work to do.
“The same kinds of problems that go into wrongful convictions in other states certainly exist in Wisconsin,” he said. “We’re ahead of the boat on some things but that doesn’t mean it can’t happen and won’t happen.”


Saturday’s event is free and open to the public.
Read the full story here and get details on attending the event. (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 07/24/08)


Watch a video interview with Chris Ochoa here.
The Milwaukee event on Saturday comes on the heels of successful community events addressing wrongful convictions around the country.


In May, the Texas Senate held a major Summit on Wrongful Convictions and another panel addressed the problem in the Dallas area last week. Earlier this month, a New York State Senate task force addressed reforms to prevent wrongful convictions.


Organize an event in your area to raise awareness about wrongful convictions. Get started here.

Inquiry hears horror tales of injustice

At hearing in Houston July 18,immigrant workers who had beenarrested in ICE raid.


At Houston prisons hearing, July 18.Left front, Wilma johnson, mother andTeresa Turner, cousin of Lonnie Johnson,executed last summer. Behind themis Njeri Shakur from the Texas DeathPenalty Abolition Movement.
WW photos: Gloria Rubac

By Gloria Rubac Houston
Published Jul 24, 2008 11:40 PM








“I’ve been stunned. I’ve been shocked. I’ve been deeply moved by what I have heard today,” said U.S. Congressperson John Conyers after hundreds of people crammed into Houston’s City Hall on July 18 to give testimony at an Inquiry of Crime, Justice and Race in Harris County. Conyers is chair of the House Judiciary Committee.

The inquiry was hosted by Texas Congressperson Sheila Jackson-Lee and organized by her staff, along with the Coalition for Justice. Preparations for the hearing began last winter after revelations of shocking racist and sexist e-mails sent by the Harris County District Attorney.

The hearing attracted community leaders, grassroots activists, and dozens and dozens of victims of the criminal justice system. When the City Council chambers could no longer hold the crowd, an overflow room was set up with television monitors for those who kept arriving.

Joining Conyers and Jackson-Lee on the panel were Texas state legislators and Houston City Council members.

Speaker after speaker condemned the criminal justice system for being systemically racist and uninterested in true justice. Applause broke out many times and signs were hoisted that read, “Houston, we have a problem!” and “Time to clean house!”

Jose Saavedra cried as he told the panel how his mother died in the county jail after being arrested for a minor traffic ticket. She was diabetic and was refused the insulin she needed, he said. She had also injured her knee in the jail and was denied treatment for that. “There is a problem at the jail,” he stressed. “We could not get any medical care for my mother. She told us they were not caring for her, but we couldn’t get the jail to do anything. We are young and we have lost our mother. And over a ticket?”

Long-time immigrant rights advocate Maria Jimenez spoke about a raid in June by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) at a local rag factory. Over a dozen people who had been arrested in the raid stood up with her in the chambers. The workers, mostly women, attended the hearing with their children.

Brothers Sean Ibarra and Erik Ibarra told how Harris County deputies stormed into their home six years ago as Sean was taking photos of deputies’ misconduct toward his neighbors. “They beat my brother and almost beat my mother, pulled guns on my mother and brother, stole evidence, stole my film, and filed false charges on us and arrested us. We tried to have the sheriff investigate these deputies and he did nothing. Six years later, they still work for the sheriff. They have not even been investigated or disciplined,” said Sean Ibarra.

The brothers recently won a $1.7 million lawsuit against Harris County.

Stephanie Storey was engaged to Hernando Torres, one of two men shot and killed by vigilante Joe Horn in November of 2007. “I want justice for these men. They shouldn’t have been burglarizing the house, but they never got to face a jury. Joe Horn was their judge, jury and executioner. Horn took the law into his own hands. This is not right. I want this case to be presented to another grand jury so they can investigate the case,” she told the panel.

Invited speakers included Dallas District Attorney Craig Watkins, the first African American D.A. in the state of Texas. “We run our office in Dallas with the goal of seeking justice, not convictions,” he told the inquiry panel.

Over 20 innocent people have been released from prison since Watkins took office in January of 2007. Many had served 15 to 25 years and were exonerated after DNA evidence was examined. Watkins has told prisoners convicted in Dallas County that, if they claim innocence, his office will investigate. He has allowed the Innocence Project of Texas to have space in the D.A.’s office and its volunteers work with assistant district attornies to look into cases of innocence.

Many people left the three-hour hearing frustrated because they had not been called to testify. Dozens turned in written reports of abuse because time expired before they could speak. Relatives of those locked in prison or executed submitted information on behalf of their loved ones.

The mothers of Lonnie Johnson, executed on July 24, 2007, and Joseph Nichols, executed on March 7, 2007, submitted information of prosecutorial misconduct in the cases of their sons, who they both said were innocent. Regina Schmahl Guidry submitted documentation on the wrongful conviction of her husband, Howard Guidry, who is a prisoners’ rights activist on Texas death row.

The Judiciary Committee staff will review statements and submitted documents to determine if a full congressional hearing by the committee should be held, Conyers said after the hearing.

Released from death row, but not exonerated


Paul Gregory House has known many prisons.

Death row. His own body ravaged by multiple sclerosis. A long, legal limbo that traps him between judges who have said he may be innocent — and state prosecutors who have refused to give up.

On July 2, unable to walk or feed himself, he was wheeled out of a hospital prison in Nashville, Tennessee, turned over to his mother, fitted with an electronic tracking bracelet, and placed under house arrest. His new trial for first-degree murder is scheduled to begin Oct. 14.

This time, Union County District Attorney General Paul Phillips will not seek the death penalty. But he still thinks House should be incarcerated for the rest of his life.

For 22 years, House has been blamed for raping and killing a neighbor in the clannish, dirt-poor hills of eastern Tennessee's Union County, a place where even in the 1980s, some houses still lacked indoor plumbing.

He was sentenced to death in 1986. Since then, his appeals have bumped up and down a long legal staircase, ultimately reaching the U.S. Supreme Court, which questioned his guilt in a landmark 2006 ruling and ordered a new trial.

No "reasonable juror," the high court said, would have convicted House after seeing DNA results, a testing technology not available at the time of his trial. Nor, the justices noted, would jurors have been convinced beyond a reasonable doubt if they had heard witnesses — who did not come forward until years later — describe the victim's husband as a drunken abuser who confessed to killing her.

A federal judge ordered House released pending a new trial. But he stayed locked up for two more years while state prosecutors filed procedural challenges.

He remains accused.

___

On July 14, 1985, people were looking for Carolyn Muncey, a 29-year-old mother of two young children. She had been missing for at least 12 hours from her home, a four-room shack without running water; her husband, Hubert "Little Hube" Muncey, said he was out drinking beer at a local dance the night she disappeared.

Around 3 p.m, they found her shoeless body in a roadside ditch. She was lying on her side, her hands bloodstained to the wrists. Her floral housecoat had cinched under her armpits, as if she had been dragged by her legs, which were scratched and bruised, across the wooded hills.

She had been an attractive woman before someone blackened her eye, left a necklace of bruises around her throat and hit her hard enough to dislodge her brain from its moorings — a blow the coroner said caused her death.

Authorities claimed House lured Muncey from her dilapidated cabin, beat her, killed her, and then dumped her body in a branch-filled culvert about 100 yards (90 meters) up the road from her driveway.

There were no witnesses. The evidence was circumstantial: semen stains on her white cotton panties and silky green nightgown; a pair of muddy jeans with reddish spots belonging to House.

Guilty, the jury said. And it spent less than four hours deciding he should be put to death.

But during the trial, a drunken "Little Hube" stumbled into another gathering, lifelong neighbor Penny Letner later claimed. Appearing "pretty well blistered ... he went to crying and was talking about his wife and how it happened and how he didn't mean to do it," she said during a 1999 federal appeal hearing.

Muncey said the couple had been arguing that night, Letner recounted, and "he said he smacked her and that she fell and hit her head. He said 'I didn't mean to do it, but I had to get rid of her because I didn't want to be charged with murder.'"

Letner's sister, Kathy Parker, was there to hear his story, too. "I freaked out and run him off," she testified.

The women and three others testified that "Little Hube" was a violent drinker who regularly beat his wife, sometimes in public. One neighbor said he had asked her for an alibi on the night of the murder.

Parker testified she had gone down to the courthouse after Muncey's visit, and spent two days waiting to give a statement, but no one came to take it.

Meanwhile, new DNA testing produced incongruous results, making his case one of the more puzzling among 218 DNA exonerations and some 115 execution reversals in this country since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976.

Genetic testing exonerated him as a rapist — the semen on Carolyn Muncey's clothes belonged to her husband. But it implicated him as a killer — the blood on House's jeans was hers.

In a narrow, bitter 2004 ruling, the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati rejected the new testimony and DNA evidence. The 8-7 ruling prompted strong dissenting opinions. Justice Ronald L. Gilman called the case "a real-life murder mystery, an authentic 'who-done-it' where the wrong man may be executed."

Muncey has long denied killing his wife or confessing to it.

___

District Attorney General Phillips is a determined man who has consistently said House killed Muncey to keep her from telling anyone that he raped her.

But most recently, in conversations with The Associated Press earlier this month, he said he may drop the case if genetic analyses now being conducted — on crime scene evidence never before tested — shows a third party's DNA. That is the first time Phillips has raised the possibility of giving up.

Did he and the state of Tennessee send an innocent man to death row?

They had some help from House, himself. Even federal public defender Steve Kissinger acknowledges his client undermined his own case, beginning with lying about where he was on the night of the murder.

He told investigators he had been home all night with his live-in girlfriend. Then investigators found those stained jeans in the couple's laundry hamper.

House admitted he had not told the whole truth.

He had taken a walk at about 10:30 p.m. He said he had left out that part because he feared that without an airtight alibi, he would become the prime suspect. He was on parole for a rape committed in Utah.

House also had what seemed to be a dubious explanation for new scratches and bruises on his hands and arms: While he was out walking, a white truck had pulled up behind him. Its occupants jumped out and tried to grab him on the dark road, yelling that he was not welcome in these parts and firing shots him.

House said he never saw his attackers. He ran headlong through pitch-black hills and brambles, losing his tank top and one of his shoes in the process, he said. He returned to his girlfriend's home about an hour later. That period roughly coincided with the coroner's two-hour window for Carolyn Muncey's time of death.

The account begged credibility — except that House and his mother were outsiders to Union County. Joyce House had recently married a local man and moved there from outside Knoxville. Her son had come only a few months before the killing, fresh from prison. Both were mistrusted by some locals — hard people born by hard country.

That same distrust may have figured in his easy conviction.

"He had long hair," Kissinger said. "He didn't work like everyone else did, he was living off his mom. Then he was kind of living off his girlfriend, too. He didn't fit with these people. And these people are very, very loyal to each other."

Why did some wait years before coming forward to testify that Hubert Muncey had confessed? "People heard that her blood was on his jeans and there was semen evidence," Kissinger said. "So why say anything?"

The blood on House's jeans was a big problem, but there was an explanation.

Dr. Cleland Blake, the assistant chief medical examiner for Tennessee, testified in 1999 that the blood on House's pants came from vials taken during Muncey's autopsy. House's lawyers provided two scenarios: either the tubes spilled on the way to the FBI testing laboratory, while House's jeans and Muncey's blood samples were placed in the same container, or someone tampered with the evidence.

There is no disagreement that a tube and a half of blood disappeared. Photos now part of the court file show blood on the outside of the emptied tubes and inside the Styrofoam storage container.

___

Paul House, now 46, sits in his mother's house about 100 miles (160 kilometers) east of Nashville, trembling and jerking from a disease gnawing his nervous system. He slurs because of the advanced stage of his disease, but his humor is sharp.

Asked how he was doing, he laughed. "I'm all right. I just had a big lunch."

House says he is not worried about the prosecutor or the future. "Paul Phillips is a fool," he said. "I really don't think there's going to be a trial. They pretty much don't have any evidence."

Phillips still considers House a menace.

"The fact that he has MS and is confined to a wheelchair does not protect the community," Phillips said. "He is a person who tricks others into positions of vulnerability."

Joyce House does not believe he will ever abandon the case against her son: "He just don't want to admit he's made a mistake."

The federal public defender says that is the reason Phillips won't let go.

"How can you live with yourself if you admit that you took away the last healthy years of a man's life?" Kissinger said. "That's a big burden."

Tuesday, 22 July 2008

Death Penalty Questioned


COLUMBIA - Organizers of the anti-death penalty event used a man who spent 17 years on Missouri death row as an example of errors in the system.

A jury convicted Joe Amrine of murder back in 1985 and gave him the death penalty; but the courts took another look at his case, and in 2003 Amrine walked free.

Amrine was in Columbia Monday to speak out against the death penalty. Amrine spoke to the gathering about how his case is a prime example of why the state of Missouri needs to take a closer look at its capital punishment policies.

For Amrine the past five years of freedom have had some mixed emotions.


"It's been hell. I mean, for real, it's been rough, for real," Amrine said. "I mean I wouldn't give it back for the world, but it's really been rough."


After spending 17 years on death row for a crime he did not commit, Amrine is speaking out against the death penalty.


"I'm living proof that innocent people do get put on death row, and I'm hoping that my presence here may have an impact," Amrine said.


The meeting in downtown Columbia brought together public citizens, politicians, and Amrine himself, all speaking out against the death penalty.


"It's time for us to re-evaluate Missouri's death penalty," Amrine said.

But a lawyer and former police officer says the death penalty does have its place.


"Well, in some cases I think the death penalty is approriate," Columbia attorney Stephen Wyse said. "And frankly in some cases I think it prevents additional violence."


But the opponents just want to use Amrine's anniversary as a time to reconsider.


"The time is now for at least this review," death penalty opponent Jeff Stack said. "We want to have a system in place that is fair, reasonable and just."

The meeting also featured brief speeches from area candidates for state legislature.

Reported by Syed Shabbir


Sunday, 20 July 2008

Lancaster event focuses attention on DNA exonerations


07:05 PM CDT on Saturday, July 19, 2008


By FRANK TREJO / The Dallas Morning News ftrejo@dallasnews.com

The use of DNA testing to clear those wrongfully convicted of crimes, and the lessons that have been learned through exonerations in Dallas County, took center stage Saturday during panel discussions that attracted local, state and federal officials to Lancaster.

The event at Cedar Valley College, organized by U.S. Rep Eddie Bernice Johnson, D-Dallas, focused attention on the cases of 18 men convicted of crimes in Dallas County who have been exonerated through the use of DNA testing. Some of the men spent decades behinds bars.

Three of those who have been freed spoke Saturday about the impact the convictions had on their lives and their efforts to adjust to life outside prison walls.

Ms. Johnson said no one would argue that those who commit crimes should be punished, but she added that the panel discussions were about those who are innocent and are convicted.

“There is perhaps no greater failure in our democracy and our justice system than the conviction and incarceration of those who have been wrongfully accused,” Ms. Johnson said. “Today we will examine what went wrong — how these men and many others were wrongfully convicted.”

Among the participants was U.S. Rep. John Conyers, D-Mich., who said the DNA exonerations in Dallas are helping to spark a national examination of the issue.

“I consider this to be very important in bringing us a little bit closer to justice,” said Mr. Conyers, who is chairman of the House Judiciary Committee. “More and more people are beginning to hear about this problem.”

Also participating in the panels were Dallas County District Attorney Craig Watkins; state Sen. Rodney Ellis, D-Houston; state District Judge John Creuzot; and Jeff Blackburn, chief counsel for the Innocence Project of Texas.

Charles Chatman, who was released in January after 27 years in prison for a wrongful aggravated rape conviction, said he wanted to remind people that others in similar situations still remain in prisons.

“We need to get out to the public that we still have work to do,” Mr. Chatman said.

Similar thoughts were echoed by James Woodard, who served 27 years in prison for a murder he did not commit.

DNA testing, Mr. Woodard said, presented an opportunity to show the “prosecutorial misconduct” that occurred in his case.

Billy James Smith, who was released from prison two years ago this month after DNA testing, had served 19 years for aggravated sexual assault.

Mr. Smith said he has tried to move on with his life. He now has a job as a delivery truck driver, but he acknowledged that he sometimes struggles. He said he sometimes is afraid of being around women, concerned that they might accidentally touch.

“The most difficult thing is when I have to tell people I was in prison and what happened to me. And then the next difficult thing is when they ask me if I’m getting compensation, like if that was the most important thing,” he said. “The most important thing is to be stable and to be able to function.”

Thursday, 17 July 2008

The Causes of Wrongful Conviction

By PAUL CRAIG ROBERTS


The execution of an innocent person cannot be remedied. This fact, together with mounting evidence of innocents on death row, has strengthened opposition to the death penalty.

Download Acrobat PDF file of article (8pp., 46 K)

Louisiana pays a pittance for 26 years of wrongful imprisonment


Rickey Johnson knows $150,000 is not adequate payback for the decades he wrongly spent in the Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola. But he also knows it can mean a fresh start when he needs it most. Johnson, who was freed earlier this year when he was cleared of the rape he served 26 years for, will get the money thanks to Rep. Frankie Howard, R-Many. Gov. Bobby Jindal endorsed the $150,000 in reparations. It will be paid from the general fund for the fiscal year 2007-08.

Johnson learned to craft leather in prison and says he has the leather works business he wants to open here in his hometown ‘‘mapped out.’’ He says he’s just trying to put his life together the best he can, and that means making the best of everything. Howard says Johnson could get his money as early as this month. Howard had sought an additional $40,000 for Johnson, but that was not approved with the supplemental bill.

Johnson was released in January based on DNA results proving his innocence, according to the Innocence Project, which represented him. “Rickey Johnson lost more than a quarter of a century, nearly his entire adult life, to a wrongful conviction. He had three young children when he was arrested, and a fourth was born shortly after he was incarcerated; all of those children are now adults,” said Vanessa Potkin, the Innocence Project staff attorney representing Johnson. “Rickey Johnson’s long nightmare will be in vain if we don’t learn from it and make sure other people in Louisiana have access to DNA testing that can prove their innocence.”

Johnson was arrested in 1982 for the rape of a woman in Many in July 1982. The victim said a man broke into her home at 1 a.m. and stayed for several hours, during which he raped her. She later identified Johnson in a photo array that included an old photo of Johnson and just two other photos. Johnson was convicted of the rape in January 1983 and sentenced to life without parole. He has been at Louisiana’s Angola Farm Prison ever since.

Ironically, he served his prison sentence alongside the man who was later convicted of the crime for which Johnson was serving. The two became acquaintances while in prison, though they never discussed their charges, Johnson said.

In June 2007, the Innocence Project (which is affiliated with Cardozo School of Law) asked Sabine Parish District Attorney Don Burkett to agree to DNA testing on a vaginal swab collected after the rape. Within days, Burkett agreed, and testing was conducted. The DNA profile did not match Johnson, and late last week, state officials entered the DNA profile in a database of convicted offenders -- yielding a match to John Carnell McNeal, who was already in prison for a rape in the same apartment complex just nine months after the rape for which Johnson was wrongfully convicted.

After McNeal was convicted of the April 1983 rape, he was sentenced to life without parole. “If police and prosecutors had not focused on Rickey Johnson so early in their investigation -- and if a proper eyewitness identification procedure had been used instead of a deeply flawed photo lineup -- the real perpetrator might have been brought to justice sooner and might not have been free to rape another woman in the same apartment complex,” Potkin said. “Anyone who doubts that our criminal justice system is stronger when we take steps to prevent wrongful convictions should take a close look at Rickey Johnson’s case.”

Original report here